
Which AA Lithium Rechargeable Battery Brand Wins?
In our test we compared 23 aa lithium rechargeable battery options head to head. Vapcell came out on top. See the measured results, the runner-up, the budget pick, and a link to the full test video.

Vapcell
Price shown in test: $35.28 for four batteries ($8.82 each), the most expensive of the 11 lithium brands tested
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Smart Tools
Price shown in test: $16.99 for four batteries ($4.25 each), the least expensive of the 11 lithium brands tested
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The quick take
The short version of why each pick lands where it does, built straight from the measured results.
“so which lithium rechargeable battery is best the vap cell seems the best but it's also very expensive for that reason i would probably go with smart tools just to experiment to see if you like this style of battery”
Placed top three in 1 of 4 measurements.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.
Category
- 12Rayovac
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test (see videoNotes), tested after nearly 2 years (700+ days) of outdoor use in solar rechargeable lights
- 13Thunderbolt
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 14Amazon Basics Black
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 15Amazon Basics Silver
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 16Energizer
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 17EBL
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 18Panasonic Eneloop
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test; also used throughout the PRIMARY lithium-vs-NiMH comparison as the baseline reference battery (fan runtime, voltage/bar-count demo)
- 19Ikea Ladda
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 20Duracell
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 21PowerEx
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test
- 22Varta
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test; entered the longevity test a few months late
- 23Active Energy
NiMH, secondary/follow-up test; entered the longevity test a few months late (same cohort as Varta)
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
Spec
- 1Vapcell
rated 1,800 mAh (2.7 Wh), protection circuit in the anode, made in China
- 2Smart Tools
rated 2,600 mWh, type-C rechargeable via included adapter, charges two batteries at once, rated for 1,200 charge cycles, made in China
- 3AmpTorrent
rated 3,000 mWh, the most ambitious capacity claim of all 11 lithium brands; kit includes 4 batteries, a charger, and a cable; made in China
- 4Pownergy
rated 2,960 mWh, 5V USB direct charging, all four batteries can be charged at once, solid red LED while charging, made in China
- 5Optic Plus
rated 2,800 mWh, 1.8 hour fast charge, magnetic absorption, rated for 1,000 charge cycles, requires the included battery charger, made in China
- 6Maxwel
rated 2,600 mWh, type-C rechargeable, comes with an adapter to charge two batteries at once, rated for 1,200 charge cycles, made in China
- 7Blackube
rated 2,775 mWh (also stated as 1,850 mAh), lithium-ion technology, up to 2,000 mA output current, rated for 1,000 charge cycles, all four batteries chargeable at once, made in China
- 8Tenavolts
rated 2,775 mWh (also stated as 1,850 mAh), rated for 1,000 charge cycles, solid blue LED while charging, made in China
- 9Sorbo
lithium polymer, rated 1,200 mAh, low self-discharge claimed, rated 1 amp continuous output, made in China
- 10Safeloop
lithium-ion technology, rated for up to 1,000 charge cycles, micro-USB charging, includes a protection circuit, all four batteries chargeable at once, made in China
- 11Maxlithium
max continuous discharge 1 amp claimed on the packaging, though the battery itself is printed with 800 mA; rated 2.8 Wh, rated for over 300 cycles, made in China
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Weight
- 1Vapcell19.4 g
the heaviest lithium battery tested
- 2Smart Tools18.6 g
5 g lighter than a Kirkland alkaline AA and 8 g lighter than an Eneloop NiMH AA
- 3AmpTorrent19.6 g
the heaviest lithium battery tested up to that point in the video
- 4Pownergy18.97 g
the heaviest lithium battery tested up to that point at its position in the video
- 5Optic Plus17.7 g
nearly a gram lighter than Smart Tools
- 6Maxwel18.3 g
- 7Blackubejust under18 g
- 8Tenavolts17.9 g
- 9Sorbo13.9 g
by far the lightest lithium battery tested
- 10Safeloop16.2 g
second-lightest lithium battery tested
- 11Maxlithium17.4 g
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Diameter
- 1Vapcell14.24 mm
- 2Smart Tools13.99 mm
- 3AmpTorrent14.19 mm
- 4Pownergy13.98 mm
- 5Optic Plus13.99 mm
same as Smart Tools
- 6Maxwel13.98 mm
- 7Blackube14.03 mm
- 8Tenavolts13.99 mm
- 9Sorbo14.03 mm
same as the Kirkland alkaline reference battery
- 10Safeloop14.39 mm
the largest diameter of all 11 lithium brands
- 11Maxlithium13.97 mm
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Capacity, rated vs actual
- 1Vapcell
rated 1,800 mAh, actually produced about 1,999 mAh, the only one of the 11 lithium brands to EXCEED its advertised rating (by almost 200 mAh)
- 2Smart Tools
rated 2,600 mWh / 1,733 mAh, actually produced 1,470 mAh
- 3AmpTorrent
rated 3,000 mWh / 2,000 mAh, actually produced 1,988 mAh, described as very impressive and coming very close to its rating
- 4Pownergy
rated 2,960 mWh / 1,973 mAh, actually produced 1,751 mAh, taking the capacity lead from Optic Plus at that point
- 5Optic Plus
rated 2,800 mWh / 1,866 mAh, actually produced 1,606 mAh, taking the capacity lead from Smart Tools at that point
- 6Maxwel
rated 2,600 mWh / 1,733 mAh, actually produced 1,436 mAh, almost 300 mAh short of its rating
- 7Blackube
rated 1,850 mAh / 2,775 mWh, actually produced 1,830 mAh, described as doing fairly well
- 8Tenavolts
rated 1,850 mAh, actually produced 1,692 mAh, coming up a little short
- 9Sorbo
rated 1,200 mAh, actually produced only 959 mAh
- 10Safeloop
rated 1,250 mAh, actually produced 1,103 mAh
- 11Maxlithium
rated 2,800 mWh / 1,866 mAh, actually produced only 1,593 mAh
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Fan runtime test
- 1Vapcell233 minutes
the longest of all 11 lithium brands, 45 minutes longer than any other lithium brand (though 22 minutes shorter than the eneloop NiMH reference battery's 255 minutes)
- 2Smart Tools193 minutes
second-longest of the 11 lithium brands (after Vapcell)
- 3AmpTorrent188 minutes
third-longest of the 11 lithium brands
- 4Pownergy179 minutes
- 5Optic Plus186 minutes
explicitly identified in the transcript as 'the second least expensive brand,' which by price matches Optic Plus
- 6Maxwel172 minutes
- 7Blackube168 minutes
- 8Tenavolts154 minutes
- 9Sorbo102 minutes
the first (worst) lithium brand to give up in the fan endurance test
- 10Safeloop115 minutes
second-worst of the 11 lithium brands
- 11Maxlithium144 minutes
third-worst of the 11 lithium brands; also struggled with RPM from the start of the fan test, running noticeably slower than most other brands
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Voltage under 250 mA load
- 3AmpTorrent
dropped only to 1.43 V, doing well at the start of the test
- 4Pownergy
dropped to 1.43 V, the best (highest) reading up to that point
- 5Optic Plus
dropped to 1.25 V
- 6Maxwel
dropped to 1.4 V
- 7Blackube
dropped to 1.41 V
- 8Tenavolts
dropped to 1.39 V
- 9Sorbo
dropped to 1.4 V
- 10Safeloop
a pretty big drop to 1.25 V at the start of the test
- 11Maxlithium
dropped only to 1.43 V, doing well at the start of the test
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Capacity, rated vs actual after 700 days
- 12Rayovac
rated 1,350 mAh, produced 1,116 mAh, down 151 mAh from the prior year's measurement
- 13Thunderbolt
rated 2,200 mAh, produced only 1,676 mAh, down 409 mAh from the prior year, the largest year-over-year capacity drop of the 12 NiMH brands
- 14Amazon Basics Black
rated 1,900 mAh, produced 1,117 mAh, down 162 mAh from the prior year; narrator notes it is 'no longer functioning properly'
- 16Energizer
rated 2,000 mAh, produced 1,858 mAh (transcript states this with an extra stray digit as '1 1858', read here as 1,858), down 61 mAh from the prior year
- 17EBL
rated 2,800 mAh, produced 2,331 mAh, transcript states this is 'down 61 from a year ago,' the exact same year-over-year drop figure stated for Energizer; kept as stated but flagged as a possible caption duplication rather than corrected
- 18Panasonic Eneloop
rated 1,900 mAh, produced 1,848 mAh, down only 30 mAh from the prior year, called very impressive
- 19Ikea Ladda
rated 2,450 mAh, produced 2,356 mAh, down only 32 mAh from the prior year, did very well
- 20Duracell
rated 2,450 mAh, produced 2,423 mAh, down only 65 mAh from the prior year, described as doing great
- 21PowerEx
rated 2,600 mAh, produced 2,394 mAh, down 32 mAh from the prior year
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
All measurements (6 more)+
Capacity, rated vs actual after about 1 year 9 months (not the full ~2 years)
- 22Varta
rated 2,600 mAh, produced 2,280 mAh, down 67 mAh from the prior measurement
- 23Active Energy
rated 2,100 mAh, produced only 1,309 mAh, down 165 mAh from the prior measurement, the weakest result of the 12 NiMH brands
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
Voltage under 250 mA load (start of capacity test)
- 1Vapcell
dropped to 1.38 V
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Voltage
- 2Smart Tools1.52 V
measured, close to the nominal 1.5 V lithium rating; showed 3 of 3 bars in a two-way radio test, unlike a fully charged NiMH which only showed 2 of 3 bars
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Capacity test
- 15Amazon Basics Silver
the battery analyzer REJECTED this battery due to a high voltage condition; no capacity figure could be obtained, treated as a test failure rather than a low score
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 18Panasonic Eneloopnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Fan runtime test (primary lithium comparison)
- 18Panasonic Eneloop255 minutes
the longest of every battery in the fan endurance test (23 minutes longer than Vapcell, the best lithium brand), despite running at a noticeably lower RPM throughout due to its lower voltage
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
Voltage/signal-bar demo
- 18Panasonic Eneloop
fully charged, measured 1.42 V (nominal 1.2 V) and only showed 2 of 3 signal bars in a two-way radio, versus 3 of 3 bars for both a fresh alkaline battery and the lithium rechargeables
- 1Vapcellnot tested
- 2Smart Toolsnot tested
- 3AmpTorrentnot tested
- 4Pownergynot tested
- 5Optic Plusnot tested
- 6Maxwelnot tested
- 7Blackubenot tested
- 8Tenavoltsnot tested
- 9Sorbonot tested
- 10Safeloopnot tested
- 11Maxlithiumnot tested
- 12Rayovacnot tested
- 13Thunderboltnot tested
- 14Amazon Basics Blacknot tested
- 15Amazon Basics Silvernot tested
- 16Energizernot tested
- 17EBLnot tested
- 19Ikea Laddanot tested
- 20Duracellnot tested
- 21PowerExnot tested
- 22Vartanot tested
- 23Active Energynot tested
How it was tested
- battery weight
- battery diameter
- voltage under a 250 mA moderate load (lithium batteries)
- milliamp-hour capacity, rated vs actual (both categories)
- fan runtime endurance test (lithium batteries vs an Eneloop NiMH reference)
- voltage and device signal-bar behavior (lithium vs NiMH vs alkaline)
- capacity retention after nearly 2 years / 700+ days of outdoor solar-light use (NiMH batteries only)
“so which lithium rechargeable battery is best the vap cell seems the best but it's also very expensive for that reason i would probably go with smart tools just to experiment to see if you like this style of battery”
Data notes and caveats
DUAL-CATEGORY VIDEO: the primary, title-framed category is a head-to-head of 11 AA lithium rechargeable battery brands (Vapcell, Smart Tools, AmpTorrent, Pownergy, Optic Plus, Maxwel, Blackube, Tenavolts, Sorbo, Safeloop, Maxlithium), for which Vapcell is the winner and Smart Tools is the explicit budget/recommended pick. The SECONDARY category is an unrelated 2-year (700+ day) longevity follow-up test on 12 NiMH rechargeable battery brands (Rayovac, Thunderbolt, Amazon Basics Black, Amazon Basics Silver, Energizer, EBL, Panasonic Eneloop, Ikea Ladda, Duracell, PowerEx, Varta, Active Energy) that had been in ongoing outdoor use in solar lights; Duracell is the explicit winner of THIS category ('after 700 days of use the duracell has the highest capacity'). Eneloop bridges both categories as the cross-comparison reference battery in the primary lithium fan-runtime test (where it actually posted the single longest runtime of all batteries tested, 255 minutes, due to running at a lower voltage/RPM throughout) as well as being one of the 12 ranked NiMH brands in the secondary test. Varta and Active Energy entered the NiMH longevity test a few months late (about 1 year 9 months of use rather than the full ~2 years) and are excluded from the closing top-6 NiMH leaderboard for that reason. Amazon Basics Silver's battery analyzer test was outright rejected due to a high voltage condition, a genuine test failure, not a missing-data gap. Several lithium brand names required heavy resolution against the description's Products Tested list, chapter titles, and the video's own explicit closing capacity/runtime recaps (used as cross-checks): Blackube appears as 'black goo'/'blackhood'/'black hub'/'blackhead'/'black ooze'; AmpTorrent appears as 'amp torque'/'antoran'; Sorbo is briefly introduced as 'high trends'; Tenavolts appears as '10 volts'/'tenavos'; and the 179-minute fan-runtime figure (introduced as 'an apology,' a phonetic dead end) was resolved to Pownergy purely by elimination against the other 10 already-placed lithium brands and the explicit closing recap list. Build note: given the fully separate product lists, test methodologies, and winners, this video is a strong candidate to be split into a lithium-AA-battery page and a NiMH-2-year-longevity page.


