
Which Brake Parts Cleaner Brand Wins?
In our test we compared 14 brake parts cleaner options head to head. Gunk (Chlorinated) came out on top. See the measured results, the runner-up, the budget pick, and a link to the full test video.

Gunk (Chlorinated)
Price shown in test: $14
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Lucas
Price shown in test: $13
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The quick take
The short version of why each pick lands where it does, built straight from the measured results.
“the chlorinated gunk came out on top with the best average finish of 3.7”
Placed top three in 1 of 4 measurements.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.
Weight
- 1Gunk Chlorinated637 g
- 2Lucas489 g
- 3CRC Chlorinated653 g
- 4Permatex504 g
- 5Johnsen's513 g
- 6Gumout397 g
of content, 483 g with can
- 7SuperTech531 g
- 8Berryman494 g
- 9CRC Non-Chlorinated518 g
- 10Denco472 g
- 11Penray462 g
- 12Sprayway555 g
- 13Detroit Axle385 g
- 143M480 g
Evaporation speed
- 1Gunk Chlorinated1 minute 24 seconds
extremely slow just like the chlorinated CRC
- 2Lucas8.3 seconds
in the top group with 3M and Berryman between 8 and 9 seconds
- 3CRC Chlorinated4 minutes 4 seconds
over eight times as long as the Gumout and Berryman, the slowest of all products tested
- 4Permatex33.1 seconds
even slower than Sprayway
- 5Johnsen's6.4 seconds2nd
second fastest overall behind Detroit Axle
- 6Gumoutclose to14 seconds
- 7SuperTech13.3 seconds
a little faster than Gumout
- 8Berryman8.8 seconds
in the top group with Lucas and 3M between 8 and 9 seconds
- 9CRC Non-Chlorinated15 seconds
just a little slower than Gumout and SuperTech
- 10Denco30 seconds
the slowest non chlorinated cleaner at that point in testing
- 11Penray12.5 seconds2nd
second place behind Berryman at that point in testing
- 12Sprayway22.44 seconds
- 13Detroit Axleclose to3 seconds
by far the fastest of all products tested, more than twice as fast as the next closest competitor
- 143M8.5 seconds
faster than average
Grease and marker removal
- 1Gunk Chlorinated3 passes
tied for first with chlorinated CRC
- 2Lucas5 passes
total
- 3CRC Chlorinated3 passes
tied for first with chlorinated Gunk
- 4Permatex4 passes
part of a three way tie for second with non chlorinated CRC and Johnsen's
- 5Johnsen's4 passes
part of a three way tie for second with non chlorinated CRC and Permatex
- 6Gumout9 passes
still had a small amount of grease and marker remaining, test stopped for lack of further progress
- 7SuperTech6 passes
faster start than Gumout
- 8Berryman8 passes
total
- 9CRC Non-Chlorinated4 passes
part of a three way tie for second with Permatex and Johnsen's
- 10Denco8 passes
to remove all grease, but did not fully remove the permanent marker stain
- 11Penray9 passes
total, same as Gumout, slow start and continued to struggle
- 12Sprayway5 passes3rd
third place behind non chlorinated CRC
- 13Detroit Axle6 passes
described as evaporating too quickly to compete with the top five brands on this test
- 143M5 passes
same as Sprayway and Lucas
Sludge removed from steel plate in 8 seconds
- 1Gunk Chlorinated75.01 g
the most of any product, circles around the competition; 0.56 g of sludge removed per gram of product (third); 5 cents per gram of sludge removed (tied third most efficient)
- 2Lucas37.22 g3rd
third place at that point in testing
- 3CRC Chlorinated58.56 g3rd
third best; 3 cents per gram of sludge removed, the most cost efficient
- 4Permatex59.27 g2nd
described as the best yet at that point; 0.67 g of sludge removed per gram of product, the best ratio of any product; 4 cents per gram of sludge removed, second most efficient
- 5Johnsen's27.48 g5th
fifth place at that point, moved ahead of non chlorinated CRC
- 6Gumout0.46 g
removed from plate (298.85 g to 298.39 g); 47 g of product used from can
- 7SuperTech0.28 g
removed from plate; 71 g of product used from can
- 8Berryman1.9 g
removed from plate (303.3 g to 301.4 g); can weight dropped from 472 g to 445.54 g, transcript states about 48 g used though the stated figures subtract to roughly 26 g, kept verbatim due to ambiguity
- 9CRC Non-Chlorinated28.2 g2nd
second place behind chlorinated CRC at that point in testing
- 10Denco15.42 g
about half of non chlorinated CRC's result
- 11Penray0.17 g
removed from plate, continued to struggle
- 12Sprayway0.45 g
removed from plate, described as not spraying with much force
- 13Detroit Axle0.24 g
removed from plate, did not pack a powerful punch
- 143M39.41 g2nd
0.57 g of sludge removed per gram of product, second best ratio
Residue
- 1Gunk Chlorinated
performed the best so far, leaving behind just one tiny spot; best possible subjective rating of one
- 2Lucas
evaporates faster than Permatex and left behind less residue
- 3CRC Chlorinated
took a very long time to evaporate but left behind only a very small amount of residue, by far the best yet at that point
- 4Permatex
very slow to evaporate and left behind quite a bit more residue than Sprayway
- 5Johnsen's
left behind a little more residue than Permatex but still performed well
- 6Gumout
left behind quite a bit of residue with an oily feel
- 7SuperTech
better than Gumout but still quite a bit of residue left behind
- 8Berryman
evaporates a little faster than chlorinated CRC but left behind some residue, better than Gumout, about the same as SuperTech
- 9CRC Non-Chlorinated
takes a little longer to evaporate than Berryman but left behind a little less residue, residue does not feel oily
- 10Denco
performed better than Gumout
- 11Penray
left behind a very thin layer of residue, similar to non chlorinated CRC, better than average
- 12Sprayway
slow to evaporate but leaves very little residue, one of the best so far
- 13Detroit Axle
left behind more residue than chlorinated CRC, performed about the same as Johnsen's
- 143M
left behind a little more residue than Detroit Axle
How it was tested
- evaporation speed timed after dragging a saturated paper towel across a table
- grease and permanent marker removal measured in number of wipe passes needed
- sludge and grime removal from a weighed steel plate measured in grams removed during an 8 second spray
- residue left behind on glass after full evaporation, assessed visually and by feel
“the chlorinated gunk came out on top with the best average finish of 3.7”


