Which Circular Saw Blade Brand Wins?
2021 test10 productsBlades, Bits & Abrasives

Which Circular Saw Blade Brand Wins?

In our test we compared 10 circular saw blade options head to head. Evolution came out on top. See the measured results, the runner-up, the budget pick, and a link to the full test video. Shoppers cross-shopping evolution circular saw blade, hercules circular saw blade and framing circular saw blade land here for the head to head that settles it.

The verdict
Evolution
Winner

Evolution

Price shown in test: $12

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Hercules
Runner-up

Hercules

Price shown in test: $10

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Milwaukee
Budget pick

Milwaukee

Price shown in test: $8

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The quick take

The short version of why each pick lands where it does, built straight from the measured results.

WinnerEvolution$12

the Japanese made Evolution came in on top at 6.08 seconds

Best in 1 of 9 measurements, including Overall Degradation.

Runner-upHercules$10

Placed top three in 2 of 9 measurements.

Budget pickMilwaukee$8

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

Weight

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    213 g

    the heaviest blade at that point in the video

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    199 g

    17 g more than the Milwaukee

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    188 g

    3 g more than the DeWalt

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    182 g

    the lightest blade tested

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    183 g

    1 g more than the Milwaukee

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    185 g

    3 g more than the Milwaukee

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    194 g
  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    344 g

    by far the heaviest blade at that point in the video

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    260 g
  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    355 g

    the heaviest blade tested

Claims

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade

    designed for demolition, but labeled not for use on ferrous metals

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)

    nonstick electric shield coating, precision laser cut vents

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade

    new tracking point amp tooth geometry

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade

    precision ground tungsten carbide teeth, thin kerf design, heat expansion slots; used as the video's control blade and is NOT advertised or designed for demolition

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)

    claims 8 times longer life, laser cut heat expansion slots, PTFE coating to reduce friction and heat build-up

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade

    patented body slot technology for smooth cuts, laser cut plate and carbide face grind

  • 7Spyder Tarantula

    polymer stabilizing vents, ultra tough nickel cobalt, claims up to 10 times longer lasting than regular blades, inner fuse anti-friction coating

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide

    speed coat anti-friction finish, brute carbide for long life; NOT marketed for framing, marketed for nail demolition

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade

    large gullets, 3/16 in kerf, extra thick steel body, claims 5 times longer life

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade

    large European style micrograin carbide tips, standard kerf size; claims to be designed for wood with nails, but labeled not recommended for ferrous, non-ferrous, or masonry

Clean Cut New 3 Passes

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    2.173rd

    2.17, 2.22 seconds; average of 2.19 seconds, third fastest of the initial round

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    2.224th

    2.22, 2.37 seconds; average of 2.27 seconds, fourth fastest of the initial round

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    2.68

    2.22, 2.52 seconds; average of 2.47 seconds, fifth of six ranked in the initial round

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    2.63

    2.47, 2.57 seconds; average of 2.56 seconds, slowest of the six blades ranked in the initial round

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    1.88

    1.66, 2.22 seconds; average of 1.92 seconds, the FASTEST blade in the initial clean-wood round

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    2.63

    2.52, 2.63 seconds; not included in the video's explicit ranked list of the six fastest new-blade averages

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    1.872nd

    1.87, 2.02 seconds; average of 1.95 seconds, second fastest of the initial round (close behind Masterforce)

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    7.62

    7.04, 6.89 seconds, much slower than the standard blades due to its thicker kerf and lower tooth count

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    10.14

    8.46, 14.6 seconds, the slowest of all blades in the initial round

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    5.16

    4.7, 4.96 seconds, described as performing fairly well given its heavy, thick-kerf design

After 30 Nails Cut

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    3.03

    3.69, 5.16 seconds; 16 of 24 teeth showed some damage

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    3.39

    4.3, 4.81 seconds; 22 of 24 teeth showed damage; had the fastest third pass of the nail test at 4.81 seconds

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    3.28

    3.89, 4.96 seconds; 17 of 24 teeth with very minor damage, held up well

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    4.86

    5.31, 9.17 seconds; 19 of 24 teeth showed damage

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    9.78

    6.28, 7.65 seconds, struggled badly and appeared to overheat mid-pass; 21 of 23 teeth showed some (mostly minor) damage

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    4.3

    5.67, 6.89 seconds; 20 of 24 teeth with very minor chipping

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    3.44

    3.95, 5.62 seconds; 16 of 24 teeth with minor damage

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    9.22

    11.81, 15 seconds; 13 of 14 teeth with very minor damage

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    19.5

    22.42, 70 seconds; the blade came loose mid-third-pass and had to be retightened before finishing; 4 of 5 teeth showed damage

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    7.24

    10.09, 15.5 seconds; 9 of 14 teeth with minor damage

Retest Clean Cut After Nails

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    4.4 seconds2nd

    second fastest of that round

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    5.42 seconds

    slightly faster than the Milwaukee

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    4.71 seconds3rd
  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    5.52 seconds

    slowest of that round

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    9.17 seconds

    the slowest of that round; the coating appeared to be causing problems

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    5.47 seconds5th
  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    4.25 seconds

    the FASTEST blade of that round

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    11.71 seconds

    a 39% slowdown from new

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    11.07 seconds

    on a fresh blade, described as only a 15% slowdown versus a worn blade's clean-cut time

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    9.89 seconds

    nearly twice its new-blade time

After Shingles

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade

    slowed significantly to 11.6 seconds (from 4.4 after nails), harder hit than most of the top blades and not among the top 5 named in that round's recap

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    8.97 seconds4th

    (from 5.42 after nails), fourth place in that round

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade

    the shingle segment states this blade slowed 'from 4.17 seconds after 30 nails to 9.12' - note this 4.17 figure conflicts with the 4.71 seconds given in the prior post-nail retest; both numbers kept verbatim as a transcript inconsistency, not resolved. Result after shingles: 9.12 seconds, fifth of the top 5 named in that round

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    10.74 seconds

    (from 5.52 after nails)

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)

    improved notably to 8.3 seconds (from 9.17 after nails) as the shingles scraped away the green coating; second place in that round

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    7.81 seconds

    (from 5.47 after nails), the FASTEST blade in that round

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    8.57 seconds3rd
  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    24.85 seconds
  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade

    the transcript separately states this blade slowed 'from 12.97 seconds before the shingles to 39.57 seconds after,' a figure that does not fully reconcile with the 11.07 second retest value above; both kept verbatim as a transcript inconsistency

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    21.65 seconds

Deck Screw Test

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade

    overheated when it hit the second deck screw and struggled badly to finish, taking 71 seconds, by far the worst deck-screw result of the lineup

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    16.07 seconds3rd
  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    11 seconds1st

    narrowly beating the DeWalt's 11.05 seconds

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade

    the transcript gives two slightly different numbers for this result: 17.74 seconds during the individual test description and 17.64 seconds in the round's recap ranking; both kept verbatim, not resolved

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    18.61 seconds

    slowed considerably after hitting the second deck screw

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    11.05 seconds2nd

    a close second behind the Diablo's 11 seconds

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    16.5 seconds4th
  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    41 seconds
  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    54.3 seconds
  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    41.6 seconds

Final Clean Cut After Full Torture

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    6.08 seconds

    the fastest of the final round, described in the transcript as coming in on top

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    7.09 seconds2nd
  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    8.1 seconds4th
  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    8.97 seconds

    slowest of the final round (nearly 4 times its new-blade time)

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    7.19 seconds3rd
  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    56 seconds

    a major failure - the host states the blade's body slot became warped from the deck-screw test, causing it to drag so badly the saw began moving backward; the blade was retested twice with no improvement

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    15 seconds

    not among the top 5 blades explicitly ranked in that round's recap, indicating a notable late slowdown despite earlier strong results

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    28.3 seconds
  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    108 seconds

    by far the worst of any blade tested

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    23.03 seconds
All measurements (3 more)+

Made In

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade

    Japan

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)

    China (professionally made for Hercules Tools)

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade

    Italy

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade

    China

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade

    China

  • 7Spyder Tarantula

    carbide and steel made in Germany, assembled in China

  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide

    China

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade

    European Union

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    not tested
  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    not tested

Teeth

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    24
  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    24
  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    24
  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    14

    fewer than the standard framing/demolition blades

  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    5

    far fewer than any other blade tested

  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    14
  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    not tested
  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    not tested
  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade
    not tested
  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    not tested

Overall Degradation

  • 1Evolution premium series framing and demolition blade
    178%

    increase in cut time from new to fully torture tested, the best (lowest) percentage increase of all blades measured

  • 2Hercules framing and demolition blade (Harbor Freight)
    215%

    increase in cut time from new to fully torture tested

  • 3Diablo Demo Demon Ultimate framing and demolition blade
    219%

    increase in cut time from new to fully torture tested

  • 4Milwaukee framing blade
    248%

    increase in cut time from new to fully torture tested

  • 5Masterforce framing and demolition blade (Menards)
    278%

    increase in cut time from new to fully torture tested, the WORST (highest) percentage increase of all blades measured

  • 6DeWalt framing and demolition blade

    not included in the video's final percentage-increase comparison list, likely because of the outlier failure result

  • 7Spyder Tarantula
    not tested
  • 8Bosch Edge extreme carbide
    not tested
  • 9Big Blue heavy duty demolition blade
    not tested
  • 10Amana Tool industrial carbide tip nail cutting blade
    not tested

How it was tested

  • cutting speed through clean 2x4 lumber (new blade, 3 passes)
  • cutting speed and tooth damage through 2x4s with 30 embedded nails (3 passes)
  • cutting speed through clean 2x4 lumber after the nail test
  • cutting speed through clean 2x4 lumber after cutting through 18 ft of shingles
  • cutting speed through 2x4s with 3 embedded deck screws
  • cutting speed through clean 2x4 lumber after the full torture test (nails + shingles + screws)
  • percentage increase in cut time from new to fully torture-tested

the Japanese made Evolution came in on top at 6.08 seconds

From the test video verdict.

Brand head-to-head scoreboards featuring this test

More Blades, Bits & Abrasives