
Which Handheld Vacuum Brand Wins?
This head-to-head test of 14 handheld vacuum options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.
Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean
Price shown in test: $29
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.
Weight
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean1.45 lb
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)3.67 lb
with 4 amp hour battery
- 3Vaclife1.49 lb
- 4KMM3/4 lb
(lightest in lineup)
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee3.28 lb
with battery
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean2.57 lb
- 7Knockoff DeWalt3.25 lb
with 4 amp hour battery
- 8Ridgid3.98 lb
(heaviest yet at that point in testing)
- 9Shark Cyclone1.52 lb
- 10Bissell2.61 lb
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)2.935 lb
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)5.89 lb
(by far the heaviest yet at that point in testing)
- 13Makita3.47 lb
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
very close to 4.6 lb
Noise (dB)
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean90.1 dB
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)93.4 dB
- 3Vaclife84.9 dB
- 4KMM83.7 dB
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee86.3 dB
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean94.5 dB
- 7Knockoff DeWalt88.1 dB
- 8Ridgid96.4 dB
(loudest yet at that point in testing)
- 9Shark Cyclone86.7 dB
- 10Bissell82.4 dB
(least noisy yet at that point in testing)
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)87.7 dB
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)85.2 dB
(relatively quiet)
- 13Makita84.8 dB
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)93.9 dB
Suction In Water
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean14 in
of water (3.5 kPa)
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)24 in
of water (6 kPa)
- 3Vaclife24 in
of water (about the same as Ryobi)
- 4KMM16 in
of water
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee42 in1st
of water, described as 'almost twice as much lift as the competition'; finished 1st overall in the suction leaderboard (Milwaukee 2nd at 36, DeWalt 3rd at 34)
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean17 in
of water, a little better than KMM
- 7Knockoff DeWalt23 in
of water
- 8Ridgid23 in
of water, same as knockoff DeWalt
- 9Shark Cyclone17 in
of water, about the same as the Dustbuster
- 10Bissell27 in2nd
of water, moved into second place behind knockoff Milwaukee at that point in testing
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)around23 in
of water
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)36 in2nd
of water, 2nd place overall in the suction leaderboard (knockoff Milwaukee 1st at 42, DeWalt 3rd at 34)
- 13Makita20 in
of water (only, struggled)
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)34 in3rd
of water, 3rd place overall in the suction leaderboard
Air Speed
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean15.62 mph
31.01 CFM
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)19.09 mph
just over 36.5 CFM
- 3Vaclife10.36 mph
19.86 CFM
- 4KMM6.65 mph
12.74 CFM
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee17.13 mph
33.74 CFM
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean19.63 mph
37.27 CFM
- 7Knockoff DeWalt12.9 mph
just under 25 CFM
- 8Ridgid19.27 mph
37.43 CFM
- 9Shark Cyclone15.18 mph
29.11 CFM
- 10Bissell13.58 mph
26.88 CFM
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)21.11 mph
40.73 CFM
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)23.04 mph3rd
just over 45 CFM; leaderboard recap lists Milwaukee at 45.09 CFM (3rd place)
- 13Makita23.47 mph1st
about 47.5 CFM; leaderboard recap lists Makita 1st overall at 47.47 CFM
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
leaderboard recap lists DeWalt at 45.22 CFM, 2nd place overall
Nut Test
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean
struggled to pick up smallest nut, finally lifted it but could not lift the second nut (4.7 g)
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)
consumed first five nuts with very little effort; lifted last two but too large for the inlet
- 3Vaclife
easy work of 6mm and 8mm nuts, struggled with 10mm, could not lift 12mm nut
- 4KMM
unable to lift and consume the smallest nut
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee
easy work of first five nuts, sixth nut almost too large but lifted and consumed it, had strength for the seventh nut
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean
easy work of first four nuts, strength for fifth and sixth, seventh too heavy
- 7Knockoff DeWalt
easy work of first three nuts, fourth nut 'danced around' before finally finishing, struggled with fifth but finished it, had strength to lift 16mm and 20mm nuts
- 8Ridgid
packing away nuts as quickly as the Ryobi; 16mm nut too large for inlet, had strength for the final two nuts
- 9Shark Cyclone
not able to lift the smallest nut
- 10Bissell
successfully packed away three nuts, that's it
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)
easy work of first five nuts, sixth a little too large, strength for final two
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)
lifted the 16mm nut but it became stuck inside the inlet; devoured nuts quickly
- 13Makita
quickly packed away first six nuts, seventh too large for the inlet
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
quick work of first five nuts, strength for final two but too large for the inlet
Sand Crevice
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean2 g
of sand left in crevice after 2 minute test (very good)
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)
finished in very close to 35 seconds
- 3Vaclife13 g
of sand left behind after 2 minute test
- 4KMM
dust bin weighed 55 g empty and 92 g after test; 62 g of sand still left in the crevice
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee
cleared all sand in 26 seconds
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean45 seconds
to pick up the sand
- 7Knockoff DeWalt49 seconds
4 seconds longer than Black & Decker Dustbuster
- 8Ridgid
very close to 25 seconds, with a small amount of sand missed at the end
- 9Shark Cyclone
empty dust bin weighed 152 g, weighed 241 g after test, leaving behind 11 g of sand
- 10Bissell23 seconds
fastest at that point in testing
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)around26 seconds
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)11 seconds
very fast
- 13Makita23 seconds3rd
tied for third place with Bissell
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)10 seconds1st
1st place overall, beat the Milwaukee
Sand Retention
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean
performed very well, did not give up any of its contents
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)
started off well, but after a few twists and turns began regurgitating a little sand
- 3Vaclife
struggled, left 87 g of sand inside the dust bin
- 4KMM
leaking sand as soon as the vacuum was powered down
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee
doing a great job of holding on to the sand
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean
struggling to hold sand; 'leaking pretty badly' with an up and down shake
- 7Knockoff DeWalt
dust bin did a great job of holding on to the sand
- 8Ridgid
gave up a little sand facing downward, and a little more with an up and down shake
- 9Shark Cyclone
held on to sand with inlet facing downward but leaked a little with an up and down shake
- 10Bissell
quick at 23 seconds but lost sand once the inlet faced downward, continued losing sand with a shake
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)
great job of holding on to all the sand
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)
held on to all the sand with the inlet facing downward
- 13Makita
great job of holding on to all the sand
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
performed just as well as Milwaukee and Makita
Flour Mat Test
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean
really struggled
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)
almost perfect job, small amount of flour left in mat
- 3Vaclife
performed better than Black & Decker Quick Clean but not as well as Ryobi
- 4KMM
did better than Black & Decker Quick Clean but not as well as Ryobi or Vaclife
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee
makes the most suction in the lineup; 'amazing job,' described as 'definitely the best yet' at that point in testing, later tied for first place overall with genuine Milwaukee and DeWalt
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean
better than Quick Clean but 'didn't exactly bust the dust this time', large inlet holding back potential, no crevice attachment included
- 7Knockoff DeWalt
performed better than both Black & Decker units but not as well as Ryobi or knockoff Milwaukee
- 8Ridgid
about the same air watts as Ryobi and performed about the same as Ryobi; well, but not quite as well as knockoff Milwaukee
- 9Shark Cyclone
does not offer enough suction or airflow to compete with Ryobi, knockoff Milwaukee, and Ridgid
- 10Bissellabout30
more air watts than Shark; did better than Shark but not as well as the more powerful vacuums
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)
performed just as well as Ryobi and Ridgid despite a large inlet
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)
tied for first place overall with knockoff Milwaukee and DeWalt
- 13Makita
moves a lot of air but doesn't make much lift; really struggled compared to Milwaukee and 20-V Black & Decker
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
tied for first place overall with knockoff Milwaukee and genuine Milwaukee
All measurements (3 more)+
Made In
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Clean
Vietnam
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)
Vietnam
- 3Vaclife
China
- 4KMM
China
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee
China
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Clean
Vietnam
- 7Knockoff DeWalt
China
- 8Ridgid
Vietnam
- 9Shark Cyclone
China
- 10Bissell
Vietnam
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)
Vietnam, assembled in China
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)
Vietnam
- 13Makita
Romania
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)
Vietnam
Air (W)
- 4KMM12.7W
- 5Knockoff Milwaukee167W3rd
(3rd place overall in the air watts leaderboard)
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Cleanabout75W
- 7Knockoff DeWalt68W
- 8Ridgid
very close to 101
- 10Bissell85W
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)around110W
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)191W1st
1st place overall in the air watts leaderboard
- 13Makita112W
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)around181W2nd
2nd place overall in the air watts leaderboard
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Cleannot tested
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)not tested
- 3Vaclifenot tested
- 9Shark Cyclonenot tested
Run Time
- 13Makita50 minutes
with a 4 amp hour battery, longest run time in the lineup
- 1Black & Decker Dustbuster Quick Cleannot tested
- 2Ryobi One+ (18-V, less expensive at Home Depot)not tested
- 3Vaclifenot tested
- 4KMMnot tested
- 5Knockoff Milwaukeenot tested
- 6Black & Decker Dustbuster Advanced Cleannot tested
- 7Knockoff DeWaltnot tested
- 8Ridgidnot tested
- 9Shark Cyclonenot tested
- 10Bissellnot tested
- 11Black & Decker 20-V (cyclonic)not tested
- 12Milwaukee genuine (M18)not tested
- 14DeWalt genuine (20-V system)not tested
How it was tested
- air speed and suction test (mph/CFM in sealed test box)
- suction lift test (inches of water column)
- air watts calculation (inches of water x CFM / 8.5)
- nut lifting test (6mm to 20mm nuts)
- sand removal from crevice (2 minute timed test, residue weighed)
- sand retention test (holding contents when powered down and shaken)
- flour removal from carpet mat (three passes)
- noise level (dB measured at 18 in)
- weight
- run time (stated for Makita only)
- dust bin emptying steps


