Which Mothballs In Fuel Brand Wins?
2017 test2 productsMyths & Experiments

Which Mothballs In Fuel Brand Wins?

This head-to-head test of 2 mothballs in fuel options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.

The verdict
Ranked first

Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

All measurements (7 more)+

Engine run test (16 oz gasoline plus dissolved mothballs)

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)

    the engine stalled and would not restart; looking inside the carburetor showed a lot of white mothball material clogging it

  • 2B12 Chemtool
    not tested

Performance claim (urban legend that mothballs boost octane)

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)

    did not improve performance, in fact caused a significant issue with the way the engine ran

  • 2B12 Chemtool
    not tested

Carbon buildup inspection

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)

    quite interesting carbon buildup deposits observed on the intake valve area and just above the piston; exhaust valve looked very clean by comparison

  • 2B12 Chemtool
    not tested

Compression test

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)

    chapters list a before-mothballs baseline reading of 109 PSI, but no after-mothballs PSI figure is ever spoken in the transcript

  • 2B12 Chemtool
    not tested

Carburetor cleanup (sprayed into fuel tank, about 80 percent acetone ratio through the engine)

  • 2B12 Chemtool

    did a terrific job dissolving the mothball buildup inside the carburetor

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)
    not tested

Combustion chamber cleanup

  • 2B12 Chemtool

    softened up the buildup inside the combustion chamber, making it very soft and easy to wipe off, though some buildup still remained

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)
    not tested

Engine recovery

  • 2B12 Chemtool

    got the engine running normally again after the mothball fuel was drained and fresh fuel added

  • 1Mothballs (original formula, naphthalene)
    not tested

How it was tested

  • engine run test with mothballs dissolved in gasoline
  • carburetor and combustion chamber visual inspection for buildup and damage
  • compression test (before mothballs baseline of 109 PSI per chapter title, no after figure ever spoken)
  • B12 Chemtool remedial cleaning test after mothball damage

this mothball did not improve performance. In fact, it seems to have caused a significant issue with the way this engine runs.

From the test video verdict.
Data notes and caveats

Myth-test debunking the urban legend that mothballs in fuel boost octane or performance; mothballs instead clogged the carburetor and stalled the engine, with no head-to-head competing brand ranking. B12 Chemtool appears only as a secondary remedial cleaning product used afterward, not as a tested subject of the original myth. The chapter titled 109 PSI (Before Mothballs) implies a compression test was performed, but no after-mothballs PSI value is ever spoken or otherwise captured in the transcript; logged to data/onscreen-only.txt.

More Myths & Experiments