Which 3/8 Inch Drive Ratchets Brand Wins?
2022 test18 productsHand Tools

Which 3/8 Inch Drive Ratchets Brand Wins?

In our test we compared 18 3/8 inch drive ratchets options head to head. GearWrench came out on top. See the measured results, the runner-up, the budget pick, and a link to the full test video.

The verdict
GearWrench
Winner

GearWrench

Price shown in test: $34

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Icon Pro (Harbor Freight)
Runner-up

Icon Pro (Harbor Freight)

Price shown in test: $40 (Harbor Freight)

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

SATA
Budget pick

SATA

Price shown in test: $13

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The quick take

The short version of why each pick lands where it does, built straight from the measured results.

WinnerGearWrench$34

the GearWrench easily won this showdown, earning an A+ in every category...If I had to buy just one ratchet, the GearWrench would definitely be it.

Placed top three in 2 of 5 measurements.

Runner-upIcon Pro (Harbor Freight)$40 (Harbor Freight)

Placed top three in 1 of 4 measurements.

Budget pickSATA$13

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

Working Arc Swing Test

  • 1GearWrench
    about20 degrees2nd

    of progress per pass, tied for second place at 18 passes for a full 360 degree rotation

  • 2Icon Pro
    about20 degrees2nd

    of progress per pass, tied for second place at 18 passes

  • 3SATA
    over17 degrees

    of progress per pass, moved into the lead among early brands at just under 21 passes

  • 4Zero Degree 0 degree gearless quick release
    over20 degrees

    of progress per pass, won the working arc swing test outright at 17.5 passes

  • 5Mac Tools
    over19 degrees

    of progress per pass, 18.5 passes, a little better than Wera

  • 6Wera
    just over19 degrees

    of progress per pass, about 18.7 passes, performed almost as well as Icon Pro and GearWrench

  • 7SK Tools
    over16 degrees

    of progress per pass, 21.7 passes

  • 8Snap-on
    18 degrees

    of progress per pass, performed better than average at 20 passes

  • 9Milwaukee
    around16 degrees

    of progress per pass, 22.5 passes

  • 10Williams
    just over15 degrees

    of progress per pass, 23.7 passes

  • 11Tekton
    around16 degrees

    of progress per pass, 22.5 passes, tied with Milwaukee

  • 12DeWalt
    about15 degrees

    of progress per pass, 24 passes, the slowest of the standard ratchets tested at that point

  • 13Kobalt
    about17 degrees

    of progress per pass, tied with SATA at 20.8 passes

  • 14Craftsman stubby
    over18 degrees

    of progress per pass, the best yet at that point, took the lead at 19 passes

  • 15Husky
    around18 degrees

    of progress per pass, 20 passes, just one more than Craftsman

  • 16ARES
    about13 degrees

    of progress per pass, took the lead among the weaker early brands at 27 passes

  • 17Pittsburgh Pro

    only about 10 degrees of progress per pass in a 30 degree space, took the lead from Performance Tool at 36 passes, described as very loose with an oversized handle

  • 18Performance Tool

    the worst of all ratchets tested, 39 back and forth passes for one full 360 degree rotation

Back Drag Pressure Test

  • 1GearWrench
    209 g

    very good

  • 2Icon Pro
    669 g

    did not perform as well as GearWrench on this test

  • 3SATA
    288 g
  • 4Zero Degree 0 degree gearless quick release
    298 g

    performed great, tied with Wera

  • 5Mac Tools
    398 g

    lower pressure than Snap-on

  • 6Wera
    298 g

    performed very well, tied with Zero Degree

  • 7SK Tools
    609 g

    pretty high pressure

  • 8Snap-on
    499 g

    almost identical to Williams

  • 9Milwaukee
    499 g

    stiffer than average

  • 10Williams
    497 g

    about the same as Milwaukee

  • 11Tekton
    278 g

    a lot better than Williams or Milwaukee despite a similar arc swing result

  • 12DeWalt
    799 g

    the stiffest back drag pressure recorded at that point in testing, even stiffer than Craftsman

  • 13Kobalt
    388 g

    the highest back drag pressure recorded up to that point in testing

  • 14Craftsman stubby
    729 g

    very stiff

  • 15Husky
    389 g

    much less than Craftsman despite a similar arc swing result

  • 16ARES
    238 g

    very low pressure, described as feeling very loose

  • 17Pittsburgh Pro
    148 g

    the lowest (loosest) of all ratchets tested

  • 18Performance Tool
    698 g

Directional Lever Stiffness

  • 1GearWrench
    181 g

    the easiest to work with of all ratchets tested

  • 2Icon Pro
    326 g

    about the same as Williams

  • 3SATA
    227 g
  • 4Zero Degree 0 degree gearless quick release
    446 g

    about 1 lb of pressure

  • 5Mac Tools
    408 g

    about 100 g less than Snap-on

  • 6Wera
    364 g

    a little more force than Icon Pro

  • 7SK Tools
    970 g

    by far the stiffest directional lever of all ratchets tested

  • 8Snap-on
    503 g
  • 9Milwaukee
    226 g

    pretty easy to work with

  • 10Williams
    314 g
  • 11Tekton
    421 g

    pretty stiff

  • 12DeWalt
    611 g

    about as stiff as Husky

  • 13Kobalt
    217 g

    easy to work with

  • 14Craftsman stubby
    431 g

    about twice the pressure of most other ratchets

  • 15Husky
    653 g

    extremely stiff, about 1.5 lb of pressure

  • 16ARES
    199 g

    about the same as Pittsburgh, easy to work with

  • 17Pittsburgh Pro
    187 g

    very easy to work with

  • 18Performance Tool
    1,561 g

    (almost 3.5 lb of pressure), by far the stiffest directional lever of any ratchet tested

Failure Load Test

  • 1GearWrench
    286.2 ft lb3rd

    third place overall, drive broke but gear and pawl stayed in great shape

  • 2Icon Pro
    284.5 ft lb5th

    described as up there with Husky and GearWrench

  • 3SATA
    258 ft lb

    drive broke, gear and pawl held up fine

  • 4Zero Degree 0 degree gearless quick release
    250.9 ft lb

    drive/pin mechanism was the source of failure, some damage to plastic components

  • 5Mac Tools
    251.3 ft lb

    broke, but other than the broken handle the ratchet held up fine

  • 6Wera
    202.7 ft lb

    the weakest failure load of all ratchets tested despite being very compact

  • 7SK Tools
    267.9 ft lb

    close to average

  • 8Snap-on
    295.4 ft lb2nd

    second place overall behind Milwaukee

  • 9Milwaukee
    312.9 ft lb

    won the failure load test outright, by far the strongest ratchet tested

  • 10Williams
    273.5 ft lb

    drive snapped, gear and pawl held up fine

  • 11Tekton
    273.8 ft lb

    almost identical to Williams, some gear tooth damage

  • 12DeWalt
    230.8 ft lb

    about 55 ft lb less than Kobalt

  • 13Kobalt
    285.9 ft lb4th

    very difficult to beat at that point in testing, directional switch ejected on failure but gear and pawl stayed in great shape

  • 14Craftsman stubby
    262.1 ft lb

    the presenter accidentally damaged some already-worn teeth with an angle grinder during inspection; the pawl also experienced some damage

  • 15Husky
    283.4 ft lb

    came up a little short of Kobalt

  • 16ARES
    267.2 ft lb

    21 ft lb better than Pittsburgh

  • 17Pittsburgh Pro
    246.5 ft lb

    on the first attempt (handle bent), 239.4 ft lb on a second attempt when the drive broke, gear and pawl held up fine

  • 18Performance Tool
    58.4 ft lb

    by far the weakest of all ratchets tested; the ratchet head is made of soft metal and stretched significantly before the drive broke

Head Size

  • 1GearWrench

    shortest front to back head profile of all ratchets at just under 11 mm, and the slimmest side to side profile at 25 mm

  • 3SATA
    12.8 mm

    front to back, one of the more compact head sizes

  • 6Wera
    13.5 mm

    front to back, one of the more compact head sizes, under 30 mm side to side

  • 7SK Tools
    13.4 mm

    front to back, one of the more compact head sizes, under 30 mm side to side

  • 15Husky
    13.7 mm

    front to back, one of the more compact head sizes

  • 2Icon Pro
    not tested
  • 4Zero Degree 0 degree gearless quick release
    not tested
  • 5Mac Tools
    not tested
  • 8Snap-on
    not tested
  • 9Milwaukee
    not tested
  • 10Williams
    not tested
  • 11Tekton
    not tested
  • 12DeWalt
    not tested
  • 13Kobalt
    not tested
  • 14Craftsman stubby
    not tested
  • 16ARES
    not tested
  • 17Pittsburgh Pro
    not tested
  • 18Performance Tool
    not tested

How it was tested

  • working arc swing test measuring back and forth passes needed for a full 360 degree rotation within a 30 degree space
  • back drag pressure test using a 7/8 inch socket, fishing line, and a scale
  • ratchet head size measurement, front to back and side to side
  • directional lever switching stiffness test
  • failure load test using a Proto torque wrench tester accurate to a tenth of a foot pound

the GearWrench easily won this showdown, earning an A+ in every category...If I had to buy just one ratchet, the GearWrench would definitely be it.

From the test video verdict.

Brand head-to-head scoreboards featuring this test

More Hand Tools