
Which Bolt And Screw Extractor Brand Wins?
This head-to-head test of 20 bolt and screw extractor options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.
Craftsman
Price shown in test: $9, the least expensive bolt extractor tested
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The quick take
No single winner was declared in this test. Here is where the top-ranked pick landed, straight from the measured results.
Placed top three in 1 of 2 measurements.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.
Damaged screw extraction torque
- 1Craftsman
lost grip at only 15 in-lb, worst of the bolt-extractor group in this round, and experienced a lot of damage
- 2GearWrench
lost grip at 55 in-lb, small amount of damage
- 3Bosch 12-piece kit
the extractor broke, with the broken piece left embedded in the screw
- 4Thinpro
lost grip at 70 in-lb, the best result so far at that point in testing, small amount of damage
- 5Topec
extractor broke at 128 in-lb after gaining a very strong grip; a piece of the broken extractor stayed stuck in the screw
- 6Neiko
broke at 133 in-lb, better than Topec's 128 in-lb
- 7Irwin
struggled to gain a good grip, let go at only 39 in-lb, but held up well with only a small amount of damage
- 8Icon
broke at 135 in-lb, moving into the lead over Neiko; extractor left stuck in the screw
- 10Stahlwille
broke at 95 in-lb, moving into fourth place behind Topec
- 11Snap-on
did not break; test stopped at 201 in-lb to protect the torque adapter, the best result of all bolt extractors
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque
- 1Craftsman
broke at 91.27 ft lbs
- 2GearWrench
gave up early under 45 ft lbs; no spiral flutes, so performance depended heavily on hammered-in depth
- 3Bosch 12-piece kit
eclipsed Craftsman at over 91 ft lbs before breaking under 110 ft lbs, with extractor pieces flying everywhere
- 4Thinpro
gave up soonest of all extractors tested to that point, under 30 ft lbs, with a lot of damage
- 5Topec
lost grip at 124.2 ft lbs, third place, extractor still in very good condition
- 6Neiko
lost grip at 98.49 ft lbs, extractor still in very good condition
- 7Irwin
lost grip at 89.49 ft lbs
- 8Iconjust under136 ft lbs2nd
(135.9), second place behind Coobeast
- 10Stahlwille
lost grip at 92.8 ft lbs, minor damage
- 11Snap-on
lost grip at 102.9 ft lbs when the bolt split
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Grade 8 (hard) bolt torque
- 1Craftsman
broke at 154.8 ft lbs, second place behind Irwin
- 2GearWrenchjust under98 ft lbs
more than double its grade 3 result
- 3Bosch 12-piece kit
not tested, skipped after breaking on the grade 3 bolt
- 4Thinpro
broke early at 70.53 ft lbs, leaving a broken extractor embedded in the bolt
- 5Topec
lost grip at a figure the transcript states as '116.6 in lbs' while every other grade 8 result in this section is given in ft lbs; likely a unit caption error, kept verbatim; moved into second place behind Craftsman
- 6Neiko
lost grip at just under 68 ft lbs
- 7Irwin
broke at 197.7 ft lbs, best of all bolt extractors tested on the hard grade 8 bolt
- 8Icon
lost grip early at just under 73 ft lbs despite the strong grade 3 result
- 10Stahlwille
gave up early at 51.67 ft lbs; the flutes were too soft and became bent when pounded into position
- 11Snap-on
gave up early at just under 95 ft lbs, struggling on hard metal like the other multi-spline extractors
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Initial damaged screw test
- 12Mata1
reached only 3 in-lb of torque, far too little to extract a screw; drill bit used up and extractor described as not having an aggressive bite
- 13TNTLEAYS71 in-lb2nd
second place among screw extractors behind Grabit Pro's 115 in-lb
- 14THOSAF
lost grip at 47 in-lb, third place among screw extractors tested that round, drill experienced some wear
- 15RIYCOUWT
drill bit destroyed by a relatively soft screw; screw itself remained in very good condition, extraction failed
- 16AHYBZN Gold
gave up very early at only 20 in-lb; drill bit and extractor both badly damaged
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
reached only 11 in-lb; drill bit and extractor both experienced heavy damage
- 18Titan
very brittle, broke on contact with the screw; not enough progress to test the extractor itself
- 19SpeedOut
turned into metal dust on contact with the screw, described as super soft
- 20Grabit Pro
came out on top of all screw extractors at 115 in-lb, drill bit and extractor still in very good condition
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
Grade 3 bolt drilling retest
- 12Mata1
reached 67 in-lb before slipping; drill bit leading edge in very bad condition but extractor still in pretty good shape
- 13TNTLEAYS153 in-lb
86 in-lb better than Mata1's 67 in-lb; drill and extractor still in pretty good condition
- 14THOSAF
reached 252 in-lb, moving into the lead for that round; drill bit and extractor still in very good condition
- 15RIYCOUWT
drill bit too soft and dull, destroyed; test skipped
- 16AHYBZN Gold
drill bit too soft, gave up at 41 in-lb, not nearly enough to extract a deck screw; drill and extractor both in pretty bad condition
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
drilled into the bolt fairly well but the extractor only reached 7 in-lb of grip; drill bit used up
- 18Titan
drilled the relatively soft bolt easily; extractor performed well at 223 in-lb before losing grip, drill and extractor still in very good condition
- 19SpeedOut
still had not improved since a test 4 years earlier per the presenter; drill bit badly damaged
- 20Grabit Pro
the number 3 drill bit was not properly shaped and could not make enough progress to test the extractor
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
Final deck screw test
- 12Mata1
drill bit struggled badly and experienced a lot of damage; extractor did not offer enough grip to extract the screw
- 13TNTLEAYS
drill bit could not penetrate the screw, described as in very bad condition
- 14THOSAF
did the best job of the round at drilling into the screw, but the extractor still could not gain enough grip to extract it
- 15RIYCOUWT
brand new drill bit turned into metal dust on contact, extraction failed again
- 16AHYBZN Gold
drilled slightly better but was destroyed almost immediately; not enough progress for the extractor to gain a grip
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
made some drilling progress but not enough to be effective; extractor could not gain a good enough grip
- 18Titan
broke apart again on contact with the screw, described as definitely too brittle
- 19SpeedOut
drill melted on contact with the screw
- 20Grabit Pro
the only extractor able to successfully extract the screw, and was even able to extract additional screws without first drilling into them
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute stylesnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
All measurements (4 more)+
Damaged screw extraction torque (multi-spline style)
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
its own drill bit broke before finishing; switched to prior drill bit; extractor broke at only 88 in-lb
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque, multi-spline style
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles115.5 ft lbs
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque, spiral flute style
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles163.8 ft lbs
best of all bolt extractors tested on the grade 3 bolt, though it split the bolt
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
Grade 8 (hard) bolt torque, multi-spline style
- 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
lost grip early at 74.3 ft lbs, then broke at 148.6 ft lbs, third place
- 1Craftsmannot tested
- 2GearWrenchnot tested
- 3Bosch 12-piece kitnot tested
- 4Thinpronot tested
- 5Topecnot tested
- 6Neikonot tested
- 7Irwinnot tested
- 8Iconnot tested
- 10Stahlwillenot tested
- 11Snap-onnot tested
- 12Mata1not tested
- 13TNTLEAYSnot tested
- 14THOSAFnot tested
- 15RIYCOUWTnot tested
- 16AHYBZN Goldnot tested
- 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kitnot tested
- 18Titannot tested
- 19SpeedOutnot tested
- 20Grabit Pronot tested
How it was tested
- baseline torque to remove undamaged screws (context test, not extractor-specific)
- damaged/rounded screw extraction torque test, bolt-extractor style (in-lb)
- soft grade 3 bolt extraction torque test (ft-lb), bolt-extractor style
- hard grade 8 bolt extraction torque test (ft-lb), bolt-extractor style
- screw-extractor style drilling and extraction torque test on a damaged screw (in-lb)
- screw-extractor style drilling-into-a-grade-3-bolt retest (in-lb)
- screw-extractor style final retest on 3.5 inch deck screws driven into a 4x4


