Which Bolt And Screw Extractor Brand Wins?
2025 test20 productsHand Tools

Which Bolt And Screw Extractor Brand Wins?

This head-to-head test of 20 bolt and screw extractor options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.

The verdict
Ranked first

Craftsman

Price shown in test: $9, the least expensive bolt extractor tested

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The quick take

No single winner was declared in this test. Here is where the top-ranked pick landed, straight from the measured results.

Ranked firstCraftsman$9, the least expensive bolt extractor tested

Placed top three in 1 of 2 measurements.

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

Damaged screw extraction torque

  • 1Craftsman

    lost grip at only 15 in-lb, worst of the bolt-extractor group in this round, and experienced a lot of damage

  • 2GearWrench

    lost grip at 55 in-lb, small amount of damage

  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit

    the extractor broke, with the broken piece left embedded in the screw

  • 4Thinpro

    lost grip at 70 in-lb, the best result so far at that point in testing, small amount of damage

  • 5Topec

    extractor broke at 128 in-lb after gaining a very strong grip; a piece of the broken extractor stayed stuck in the screw

  • 6Neiko

    broke at 133 in-lb, better than Topec's 128 in-lb

  • 7Irwin

    struggled to gain a good grip, let go at only 39 in-lb, but held up well with only a small amount of damage

  • 8Icon

    broke at 135 in-lb, moving into the lead over Neiko; extractor left stuck in the screw

  • 10Stahlwille

    broke at 95 in-lb, moving into fourth place behind Topec

  • 11Snap-on

    did not break; test stopped at 201 in-lb to protect the torque adapter, the best result of all bolt extractors

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque

  • 1Craftsman

    broke at 91.27 ft lbs

  • 2GearWrench

    gave up early under 45 ft lbs; no spiral flutes, so performance depended heavily on hammered-in depth

  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit

    eclipsed Craftsman at over 91 ft lbs before breaking under 110 ft lbs, with extractor pieces flying everywhere

  • 4Thinpro

    gave up soonest of all extractors tested to that point, under 30 ft lbs, with a lot of damage

  • 5Topec

    lost grip at 124.2 ft lbs, third place, extractor still in very good condition

  • 6Neiko

    lost grip at 98.49 ft lbs, extractor still in very good condition

  • 7Irwin

    lost grip at 89.49 ft lbs

  • 8Icon
    just under136 ft lbs2nd

    (135.9), second place behind Coobeast

  • 10Stahlwille

    lost grip at 92.8 ft lbs, minor damage

  • 11Snap-on

    lost grip at 102.9 ft lbs when the bolt split

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Grade 8 (hard) bolt torque

  • 1Craftsman

    broke at 154.8 ft lbs, second place behind Irwin

  • 2GearWrench
    just under98 ft lbs

    more than double its grade 3 result

  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit

    not tested, skipped after breaking on the grade 3 bolt

  • 4Thinpro

    broke early at 70.53 ft lbs, leaving a broken extractor embedded in the bolt

  • 5Topec

    lost grip at a figure the transcript states as '116.6 in lbs' while every other grade 8 result in this section is given in ft lbs; likely a unit caption error, kept verbatim; moved into second place behind Craftsman

  • 6Neiko

    lost grip at just under 68 ft lbs

  • 7Irwin

    broke at 197.7 ft lbs, best of all bolt extractors tested on the hard grade 8 bolt

  • 8Icon

    lost grip early at just under 73 ft lbs despite the strong grade 3 result

  • 10Stahlwille

    gave up early at 51.67 ft lbs; the flutes were too soft and became bent when pounded into position

  • 11Snap-on

    gave up early at just under 95 ft lbs, struggling on hard metal like the other multi-spline extractors

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Initial damaged screw test

  • 12Mata1

    reached only 3 in-lb of torque, far too little to extract a screw; drill bit used up and extractor described as not having an aggressive bite

  • 13TNTLEAYS
    71 in-lb2nd

    second place among screw extractors behind Grabit Pro's 115 in-lb

  • 14THOSAF

    lost grip at 47 in-lb, third place among screw extractors tested that round, drill experienced some wear

  • 15RIYCOUWT

    drill bit destroyed by a relatively soft screw; screw itself remained in very good condition, extraction failed

  • 16AHYBZN Gold

    gave up very early at only 20 in-lb; drill bit and extractor both badly damaged

  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit

    reached only 11 in-lb; drill bit and extractor both experienced heavy damage

  • 18Titan

    very brittle, broke on contact with the screw; not enough progress to test the extractor itself

  • 19SpeedOut

    turned into metal dust on contact with the screw, described as super soft

  • 20Grabit Pro

    came out on top of all screw extractors at 115 in-lb, drill bit and extractor still in very good condition

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested

Grade 3 bolt drilling retest

  • 12Mata1

    reached 67 in-lb before slipping; drill bit leading edge in very bad condition but extractor still in pretty good shape

  • 13TNTLEAYS
    153 in-lb

    86 in-lb better than Mata1's 67 in-lb; drill and extractor still in pretty good condition

  • 14THOSAF

    reached 252 in-lb, moving into the lead for that round; drill bit and extractor still in very good condition

  • 15RIYCOUWT

    drill bit too soft and dull, destroyed; test skipped

  • 16AHYBZN Gold

    drill bit too soft, gave up at 41 in-lb, not nearly enough to extract a deck screw; drill and extractor both in pretty bad condition

  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit

    drilled into the bolt fairly well but the extractor only reached 7 in-lb of grip; drill bit used up

  • 18Titan

    drilled the relatively soft bolt easily; extractor performed well at 223 in-lb before losing grip, drill and extractor still in very good condition

  • 19SpeedOut

    still had not improved since a test 4 years earlier per the presenter; drill bit badly damaged

  • 20Grabit Pro

    the number 3 drill bit was not properly shaped and could not make enough progress to test the extractor

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested

Final deck screw test

  • 12Mata1

    drill bit struggled badly and experienced a lot of damage; extractor did not offer enough grip to extract the screw

  • 13TNTLEAYS

    drill bit could not penetrate the screw, described as in very bad condition

  • 14THOSAF

    did the best job of the round at drilling into the screw, but the extractor still could not gain enough grip to extract it

  • 15RIYCOUWT

    brand new drill bit turned into metal dust on contact, extraction failed again

  • 16AHYBZN Gold

    drilled slightly better but was destroyed almost immediately; not enough progress for the extractor to gain a grip

  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit

    made some drilling progress but not enough to be effective; extractor could not gain a good enough grip

  • 18Titan

    broke apart again on contact with the screw, described as definitely too brittle

  • 19SpeedOut

    drill melted on contact with the screw

  • 20Grabit Pro

    the only extractor able to successfully extract the screw, and was even able to extract additional screws without first drilling into them

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested
All measurements (4 more)+

Damaged screw extraction torque (multi-spline style)

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles

    its own drill bit broke before finishing; switched to prior drill bit; extractor broke at only 88 in-lb

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque, multi-spline style

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    115.5 ft lbs
  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Grade 3 (soft) bolt torque, spiral flute style

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles
    163.8 ft lbs

    best of all bolt extractors tested on the grade 3 bolt, though it split the bolt

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

Grade 8 (hard) bolt torque, multi-spline style

  • 9Coobeast 35-piece kit, multi-spline and spiral flute styles

    lost grip early at 74.3 ft lbs, then broke at 148.6 ft lbs, third place

  • 1Craftsman
    not tested
  • 2GearWrench
    not tested
  • 3Bosch 12-piece kit
    not tested
  • 4Thinpro
    not tested
  • 5Topec
    not tested
  • 6Neiko
    not tested
  • 7Irwin
    not tested
  • 8Icon
    not tested
  • 10Stahlwille
    not tested
  • 11Snap-on
    not tested
  • 12Mata1
    not tested
  • 13TNTLEAYS
    not tested
  • 14THOSAF
    not tested
  • 15RIYCOUWT
    not tested
  • 16AHYBZN Gold
    not tested
  • 17Yakamoz 22-piece mini damaged screw extractor kit
    not tested
  • 18Titan
    not tested
  • 19SpeedOut
    not tested
  • 20Grabit Pro
    not tested

How it was tested

  • baseline torque to remove undamaged screws (context test, not extractor-specific)
  • damaged/rounded screw extraction torque test, bolt-extractor style (in-lb)
  • soft grade 3 bolt extraction torque test (ft-lb), bolt-extractor style
  • hard grade 8 bolt extraction torque test (ft-lb), bolt-extractor style
  • screw-extractor style drilling and extraction torque test on a damaged screw (in-lb)
  • screw-extractor style drilling-into-a-grade-3-bolt retest (in-lb)
  • screw-extractor style final retest on 3.5 inch deck screws driven into a 4x4

More Hand Tools