Which Drain Opener Brand Wins?
2019 test7 productsShop Chemicals & Lubricants

Which Drain Opener Brand Wins?

This head-to-head test of 7 drain opener options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.

The verdict
Ranked first

Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

Grease

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    did a little bit better job with the bacon grease along with Liquid Plumber; final assessment groups Draino with Liquid Plumber, Clobber, and muriatic acid as effective on grease

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    described as about the same as Drano; grouped in final assessment as effective on grease with Drano, Clobber, and muriatic acid

  • 3Lye

    quite a bit of grease remained at the bottom of the cup; final assessment groups Lye with Drain Stix and Roebic as less effective on grease

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    did not seem to have done much; grouped as less effective on grease with Lye and Drain Stix

  • 5Drain Stix

    just seemed to dye the grease blue; grouped as less effective on grease with Lye and Roebic

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    Clorox (the sulfuric acid product) did a better job than muriatic acid at dissolving grease, though muriatic acid is still grouped as effective on grease in the final assessment

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    grouped as effective on grease in the final assessment alongside Drano, Liquid Plumber, and muriatic acid

Corrosion (steel pipe, nail, PVC)

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    no visible damage at 45 min; final assessment: showed a very small amount of corrosion on the steel pipe; no damage to PVC

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    no visible damage at 45 min; final assessment: showed a very small amount of corrosion on the steel pipe; no damage to PVC

  • 3Lye

    no damage to metal or PVC at 45 min; final assessment: did not cause any corrosion to the steel pipe or the nail

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    no impact on steel, nail, or PVC

  • 5Drain Stix

    no impact on paper towel, metal, or PVC besides coloring

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    began removing rust from the nail and removing plating from the pipe at 45 min, described as highly corrosive; final assessment: quite a bit of corrosion; no damage to PVC

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    removed rust from the nail and removed plating from the pipe, described as highly corrosive; final assessment: quite a bit of corrosion

Vegetables

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    no visible damage to vegetables

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    no visible damage

  • 3Lye

    color of vegetables looked a little different but not dissolved; no dissolving observed at 12 hr

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    no impact

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    no dissolving observed; narrator speculates hydrochloric acid would do a little better with a higher acid percentage

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    the only product that showed any effect at all on vegetables (small amount of progress) in the 45 min to 12 hr round

  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested

Paper towel and tape

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    no apparent damage

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    no apparent damage

  • 3Lye

    no damage

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    no impact

  • 5Drain Stix

    no impact besides coloring

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    no impact

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength
    not tested

Hair 45 min

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    did not dissolve the soap or the dog hair

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    did not dissolve the soap or the dog hair

  • 3Lye

    starting to dissolve the dog hair

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    did not seem to dissolve the hair or vegetables, but did a pretty good job on the grease

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    diluted mix did not have much impact on hair, vegetables, grease, or paper towel, but began removing rust from the nail

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner
    not tested
  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested

Hair 12 hr

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    did a little bit better job than Liquid Plumber; earned an A grade with Liquid Plumber and Lye, most effective at dissolving hair

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)

    didn't seem to do very well at dissolving the hair per the play-by-play, but the closing letter-grade summary places Liquid Plumber in the A group with Drano and Lye for hair

  • 3Lye

    did by far the best of all products tested, totally dissolving all of the hair

  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid

    did a better job thinning the hair than sulfuric acid, but not as good as lye; final letter grade B for hair (needed strong concentration over hours to be effective)

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    thinned the hair a little, less than muriatic acid and lye; final letter grade B for hair (needed strong concentration over hours to be effective)

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner
    not tested
  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested
All measurements (5 more)+

Mixing observation

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    mixed fairly well, but large particles did not seem to fully dissolve

  • 5Drain Stix

    began to dissolve fairly quickly, turning the water blue

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength
    not tested
  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)
    not tested
  • 3Lye
    not tested
  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid
    not tested
  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength
    not tested

Hair

  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner

    no impact observed on dog hair; grouped with biological products that did not seem to work

  • 5Drain Stix

    still dissolving, had not dissolved any of the hair after 45 min; no dissolving observed at 12 hr

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength
    not tested
  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)
    not tested
  • 3Lye
    not tested
  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid
    not tested
  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength
    not tested

Extended Pyrex retest (50 percent mix, 15 min)

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength

    dog hair definitely starting to disappear, described as doing a very good job dissolving hair; no apparent damage to nail; did not dissolve carrot

  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)
    not tested
  • 3Lye
    not tested
  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner
    not tested
  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested
  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid
    not tested
  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength
    not tested

Extended Pyrex retest (undiluted, higher dose, 15 min)

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    explicitly credited with removing all rust from the nail (very good job, but highly corrosive) and eating into the carrot

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength
    not tested
  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)
    not tested
  • 3Lye
    not tested
  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner
    not tested
  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested
  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid
    not tested

Extended Pyrex retest (3 hr)

  • 7Clobber sulfuric acid, professional strength

    explicitly credited with dissolving most of the hair and nearly totally dissolving the asparagus; carrot smaller and appeared greenish

  • 1Drano Max Gel Pro Strength
    not tested
  • 2Liquid Plumr Pro Strength (Liquid-Plumr)
    not tested
  • 3Lye
    not tested
  • 4Roebic Granular Drain and Trap Cleaner
    not tested
  • 5Drain Stix
    not tested
  • 6Muriatic Acid 31.45 percent hydrochloric acid
    not tested

How it was tested

  • hair and soap dissolving test at 45 minutes and again at 12 hours
  • bacon grease dissolving test
  • vegetable (carrot, asparagus) dissolving test
  • foreign object test (paper towel, tape)
  • metal pipe, rusty nail, and PVC corrosion/damage test
  • extended concentrated retest in Pyrex containers (Drano 50 percent mix vs full-strength sulfuric acid) on dog hair, rusty nail, carrot, and asparagus at 15 minutes and 3 hours
Data notes and caveats

No single overall winner: video closes with per-use-case recommendations, hair or bathroom clogs favor Liquid Plumber, Drano, or Lye, while kitchen grease or solid clogs favor acid (with a caution that acid is highly corrosive to metal plumbing and garbage disposals). Chapters (Drano, Bacon Grease, Drain sticks/Roebic/Water) only cover 3 of 7 products, so chapterMap is false. The sulfuric acid product is listed in the description as Clobber (currently not available) but narrated as Clorox and later Clabber; resolved to Clobber per description ground truth. The extended Pyrex retest narration (lines describing the 15 minute and 3 hour checks) interleaves Drano-container and acid-container results without a labeled product for every sentence; only sentences with an explicit product name were attributed, ambiguous unlabeled sentences were omitted rather than guessed.

More Shop Chemicals & Lubricants