
Which Gas Can Brand Wins?
This head-to-head test of 13 gas can options has the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.
Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
Price shown in test: $25
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.
Weight
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss2.6 lb
- 2Scepter2.6 lb
described in the closing recap as the lightest can tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System2.7 lb
- 4Midwest plastic3.2 lb
- 5Scepter Military Style3.9 lb
described as the heaviest yet at that point in testing
- 6No-Spill3.1 lb
- 7VP Racing3.7 lb
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight8.9 lb
described as by far the heaviest yet at that point in testing
- 9Stark Jerry can8.7 lb
- 10Eagle5.4 lb
- 11SureCan3.9 lb
- 12Justrite8.4 lb
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can10 lb
by far the heaviest of all 13 cans tested
Side Leak Test
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
no leaks
- 2Scepter
no leaks
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System
no leaks
- 4Midwest plastic
no leaks
- 5Scepter Military Style
no leaks
- 6No-Spill
no leaks
- 7VP Racing
no leaks initially, but the vent was opened too far and started leaking; reduced ventilation helped
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
no leaks or spills
- 9Stark Jerry can
no leaks or spills, but prone to spillage when poured quickly at full tilt since nothing holds back the flow
- 10Eagle
no fuel leaks or spills
- 11SureCan
no leaks or spills
- 12Justrite
no leaks or spills
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
no leaks, but quite a bit of spillage caused by the tester's own initial pour technique ('I didn't do the best job of getting the Wavian started')
Flow Drain Test
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
great flow for 7 seconds then slowed; finished in 3 minutes 2 seconds to drain most of the 5 gallons; a few ounces trapped inside due to the flame mitigation device
- 2Scepter
started off great, slowed slightly after several seconds; finished in 1 minute 55 seconds, over a minute faster than the Garage Boss; a few ounces trapped by the flame mitigation hardware
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System
great start, slowed a lot after about 5 seconds; finished in 2 minutes 45 seconds, 50 seconds slower than the Scepter; a small amount leaked onto the test stand from too much pressure on the press-and-pour spout
- 4Midwest plastic
slow start with poor venting when tilted nose-down; finished in 2 minutes 40 seconds, 5 seconds faster than the Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill, moving into second place at that point in testing; almost no water trapped, by far the best draining yet at that point
- 5Scepter Military Style
started with a very nice flow, but the self-venting spout ventilated poorly and the tall, narrow profile hurt performance; slowest yet at 3 minutes 30 seconds; best draining yet at that point, less than an ounce trapped inside, no fuel spillage
- 6No-Spill
decent flow rate at first, ventilation slowed it after a few seconds; drains faster than most other brands; finished in 2 minutes 5 seconds, moving into second place behind the Scepter Military Style at that point in testing; a small amount of fuel spilled from the base of the spout; fully drainable after removing the spout
- 7VP Racing
fastest yet at that point in testing, finishing in 1 minute 53 seconds; best draining so far, less than an ounce of water left, no sloshing; the fuel vent is located too close to the fuel spout, likely to leak if poured quickly with a full can
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
started off well, but ventilation became a problem quickly; needed very close to the same time as the Scepter Military Style at 3 minutes 30 seconds; didn't drain quite as well as some other cans, but the rest of the fuel came out after removing the nozzle
- 9Stark Jerry can
flow slowed after several seconds; significant ventilation issues like the other military-style cans; finished in 3 minutes 5 seconds; did a great job draining the rest of the water
- 10Eagle
fastest yet at that point in testing, finishing just after 1.5 minutes; small amount of water trapped; unrestricted fuel spout gives a big speed advantage
- 11SureCan
pretty good start, fuel spout size held it back; finished in 2 minutes 45 seconds, a little longer than average; a few ounces left but drains completely without issue
- 12Justrite
the 1 in spout made much better progress than most other brands, no ventilation issues after several seconds; finished in 1 minute 56 seconds; small amount of water trapped
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
by far the fastest and best-draining fuel can, emptying the entire contents in only 87 seconds, the fastest of all 13 cans tested; did a great job completely draining the tank
Vehicle Refuel Test
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
spout design limits the tip-up angle, a lot of fuel left in the can; over 16 lb (about 2 gallons) of water remained after subtracting the can's weight. Transcript states the can weight subtracted here as 2.7 lb, which conflicts with the 2.6 lb weight stated earlier for this same can; kept both figures, flagged as an unresolved discrepancy.
- 2Scepter
can and water combined weighed over 27 lb, close to 3 gallons of water remaining
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System
spout allows a high enough tilt angle to drain the tank; did very well with only a small amount of fuel left inside
- 4Midwest plastic
spout has plenty of length and a good angle for fueling a vehicle; can was nearly empty after the test
- 5Scepter Military Style
well designed for adding fuel to a vehicle, only a small amount of water left inside
- 6No-Spill
not designed for refueling a vehicle and really struggled; over 3 gallons of fuel still inside after the test
- 7VP Racing
very well designed, no problems draining the fuel
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
no problems draining the fuel
- 10Eagle
funnel angle was barely enough; probably would not work well with some vehicles
- 11SureCan
offers a lot of flexibility, no issues
- 12Justrite
pretty long spout helps a lot, no problems draining the fuel
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
no issues fully draining the fuel during the vehicle-refueling test
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
Made In
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
USA
- 2Scepter
USA
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System
USA
- 4Midwest plastic
USA
- 5Scepter Military Style
Canada
- 6No-Spill
USA
- 7VP Racing
USA
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
Latvia
- 10Eagle
USA
- 11SureCan
USA
- 12Justrite
USA
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
- 13Wavian NATO fuel cannot tested
Tip Over Angle
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss34 degrees
- 2Scepter39 degrees
about 5 degrees better than the Garage Boss
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System35 degrees
almost the same as the Garage Boss
- 4Midwest plastic35 degrees
about the same as the Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill
- 5Scepter Military Style25 degrees
about 10 degrees less than the other brands, worst result up to that point in testing
- 6No-Spill40 degrees2nd
took the lead at that point in testing; finished 2nd overall in the final tip-over-angle recap behind the Eagle's 47 degrees
- 7VP Racing33 degrees
- 10Eaglealmost47 degrees
the best result of all 13 cans tested, taking the lead from the No-Spill
- 11SureCan38 degrees
- 12Justrite39 degrees
tied with the regular Scepter for the 3rd-best result
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can20 degrees
tall, narrow profile, one of the worst results, similar to the Harbor Freight Midwest's 19 degrees
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freightnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
Vehicle Stability Test
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
toppled over pretty easily, eliminated in the first round alongside the Scepter Military Style
- 2Scepter
survived the first two elimination rounds ('still standing'); eliminated in a later round together with the plastic Midwest can
- 4Midwest plastic
survived the first two elimination rounds ('still standing'); eliminated in a later round together with the Scepter
- 5Scepter Military Style
toppled over pretty easily, eliminated in the first round alongside the Garage Boss
- 6No-Spill
one of the last cans standing, but 'lost its balance and almost tipped over' just before the Eagle was declared the winner, effectively finishing as runner-up in this test
- 7VP Racing
'did well, but is finally out of the running' in a middle elimination round; the transcript's headcount drops from 8 remaining cans to 5 remaining cans in this round while only VP Racing is named as eliminated, meaning two additional unnamed eliminations also happened here that the transcript does not identify; flagged as an unresolved gap
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
transcript refers to 'the Midwest military' tipping over pretty easily in a round alongside the Stark and the Wavian; interpreted as this can, since it is grouped elsewhere in the video with the Stark and Wavian as the three 'military style' metal cans; flagged as an inference since the transcript's exact wording is 'Midwest military' rather than 'Harbor Freight Midwest'
- 10Eagle
winner of the moving-vehicle stability test, the last can still standing
- 11SureCan
not explicitly named in the elimination narration; the transcript's stability section has an unresolved gap where the headcount drops by two more cans than are individually named (see VP Racing), so SureCan's exact elimination point could not be determined from the narration; flagged as unresolved
- 12Justrite
eliminated ('couldn't hold on any longer') in a later round, shortly before the No-Spill nearly tipped and the Eagle was declared the overall winner
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
'the Midwest military, Stark, and the Wavian fuel cans all tipped over pretty easily,' eliminated in the second elimination round
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
Drop Test
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Boss
transcript mentions 'the Shot Boss has a couple of pretty significant dents' during the drop test section; interpreted as a caption mishearing of 'Garage Boss' since no other candidate brand fits, flagged as an inferred resolution
- 2Scepter
transcript states 'the Scepter has sprung a leak' in the drop test section, immediately after a separate mention of the Scepter Military Style holding up well; interpreted as referring to this standard Scepter can, distinct from the military-style version, flagged as an inference
- 4Midwest plastic
held up well, but there's a lot of damage to the spout. Interpreted as this plastic Midwest can rather than the Harbor Freight metal Midwest can, since the narrator does not use a 'Harbor Freight' qualifier at this point in the drop test section; flagged as an inference.
- 5Scepter Military Style
other than the spout, held up very well
- 6No-Spill
just one dent, otherwise still in great shape
- 7VP Racing
still in great shape with no visible damage
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
transcript uses the nickname 'Wavian knockoff' ('a lot of damage to the knockoff, the handle is destroyed, and there's a lot of dents on the can'), immediately followed by a separate reference to 'the can from Harbor Freight' also sustaining 'quite a bit of damage'; interpreted here as describing this same can twice, since its construction was earlier directly compared to the Wavian's; flagged as an inference, not an explicit transcript statement
- 10Eagle
a lot of damage, handle torn off, quite a few dents
- 11SureCan
held up just fine, no damage
- 12Justrite
loose handle, a lot of dents
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
just a small dent, the best result among the cans drop-tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
All measurements (7 more)+
Corrosion Test
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
no corrosion after the test; interior is painted; noticeably thicker metal than the Stark
- 9Stark Jerry can
interior not painted, metal not galvanized; quite a bit of rust had already formed within about an hour of the test, the worst corrosion resistance of the metal cans tested
- 10Eagle
galvanized metal held up really well, no rust
- 12Justrite
constructed of galvanized metal rather than painted; no corrosion after the test
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
no visible corrosion after the test; interior is painted like the Harbor Freight Midwest
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
Description
- 9Stark Jerry can
marketed for rugged off-road use; anti-corrosive coated paint claimed inside and out; spot-welded (not solid-welded) handle, some welds unpainted; self-locking lid
- 10Eagle
24-gauge hot-dipped galvanized steel, baked-on powder coat finish, double interlock no-weld bottom seam, flame arrester screen
- 11SureCan
hand grips on the bottom, thumb trigger release on top controls the flow
- 12Justrite
small amount of assembly required; includes a 1 in hose for quick refueling; squeeze-handle valve
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freightnot tested
- 13Wavian NATO fuel cannot tested
Overall Drain Speed Leaderboard
- 7VP Racing3rd fastest
of all 13 cans in the final recap at 113 seconds, behind the Wavian (87 seconds) and Eagle (90 seconds)
- 10Eagle2nd fastest
of all 13 cans in the final recap at 90 seconds, almost as fast as the Wavian's 87 seconds
- 12Justrite
tied for 5th fastest of the top 5 fastest cans in the final recap at 116 seconds
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freightnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
- 13Wavian NATO fuel cannot tested
Handle Load Test
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
handle broke at over 2,000 lb
- 9Stark Jerry can
handle broke at 864 lb, the weakest of the three metal cans tested for handle strength; the spot welds held on
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
handle broke at 2,081 lb, the strongest of the three metal cans tested for handle strength, barely edging out the Harbor Freight Midwest's over 2,000 lb
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 10Eaglenot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
- 12Justritenot tested
Weight Load Test
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
described as 'definitely capable of taking on more weight,' no specific failure figure given
- 9Stark Jerry can
held up fine at over 2,800 lb
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
'no problems' holding weight, no specific failure figure given
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 10Eaglenot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
- 12Justritenot tested
Construction
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freight
first of four metal cans tested; solid weld attaching the handle to the can, and the entire seam connecting the two halves is also welded
- 13Wavian NATO fuel can
solid weld attaching the handle to the can, and the entire seam connecting the two halves is also welded, similar to the Harbor Freight Midwest; no manufacturer information printed on the can
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling Systemnot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
- 10Eaglenot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
- 12Justritenot tested
Material
- 3Briggs & Stratton Smart Fill Fuel Filling System
plastic blow-molded
- 1Briggs & Stratton Garage Bossnot tested
- 2Scepternot tested
- 4Midwest plasticnot tested
- 5Scepter Military Stylenot tested
- 6No-Spillnot tested
- 7VP Racingnot tested
- 8Midwest metal, sold at Harbor Freightnot tested
- 9Stark Jerry cannot tested
- 10Eaglenot tested
- 11SureCannot tested
- 12Justritenot tested
- 13Wavian NATO fuel cannot tested
How it was tested
- flow rate / drain time test (5 gallons of water, filler-neck test stand)
- leak test when tipped on its side
- static tip-over angle test (using an angle finder)
- moving-vehicle stability test (elimination-style, cans left standing in the bed of a moving vehicle)
- vehicle refueling test (simulated recessed gas port, water weighed before/after pour)
- drop test (approximately 12 ft drop)
- handle failure load test (metal military-style cans: Stark, Harbor Freight Midwest, Wavian)
- top-load weight capacity test (metal military-style cans: Stark, Harbor Freight Midwest, Wavian)
- corrosion resistance test (hydrogen peroxide, vinegar, and salt solution; metal cans: Stark, Harbor Freight Midwest, Wavian, Justrite, Eagle)


