Which Pocket/folding Knives Brand Wins?
2024 test19 productsHand Tools

Which Pocket/folding Knives Brand Wins?

In our test we compared 19 pocket/folding knives options head to head. Boker came out on top. See the measured results, the runner-up, the budget pick, and a link to the full test video.

The verdict
Boker
Winner

Boker

Price shown in test: $373

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Civivi
Runner-up

Civivi

Price shown in test: $30

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Civivi
Budget pick

Civivi

Price shown in test: $30

Check price on Amazon

Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The quick take

The short version of why each pick lands where it does, built straight from the measured results.

WinnerBoker$373

the booker came out on top with the best average finisher rating of 3.9

Placed top three in 1 of 9 measurements.

Runner-upCivivi$30

Placed top three in 1 of 9 measurements.

Budget pickCivivi$30

Placed top three in 1 of 9 measurements.

The measured results

Every number below is read straight from the test. Products are listed in the order they finished.

Weight (g)

  • 1AOSILEY
    129g

    (just over)

  • 2Albatross
    105.63g
  • 3GW

    captioned as '11 17.76%'; the leading '11' and trailing '%' do not fit any plausible weight format used elsewhere in this video and are almost certainly caption artifacts around a real figure, kept verbatim rather than guessed

  • 4Mossy Oak
    145.63g

    captioned with a leading '11 18.96%' fragment immediately before it that does not fit the video's weight format and is kept verbatim as an unresolved artifact rather than guessed

  • 5Steinbrucke

    not stated anywhere in the transcript, an apparent gap

  • 6Crescent

    not stated; the transcript reads 'a crescent is the heaviest yet at price of $20 is this Oldtimer brand' with the actual weight number missing between 'at' and the next brand's price introduction, a clear caption gap

  • 7Old Timer
    87.8g
  • 8Smith & Wesson
    99.37g

    (transcript merges this figure directly into the next sentence about CRKT with a stray '%' sign, 'the Smith and Wesson weighs 99.37% G for the crkt'; the number is attributed to Smith & Wesson by sentence position, the '%' kept as an unresolved artifact)

  • 9CRKT

    not clearly isolated; the transcript's weight sentence for this brand is merged with Smith & Wesson's ('the Smith and Wesson weighs 99.37% G for the crkt'), leaving no distinct CRKT figure, an apparent gap

  • 10Buck
    132.5g
  • 11Civivi
    just under79g
  • 12Kershaw
    121.6g
  • 13CJRB
    112.71g
  • 14Gerber

    captioned as '19.764miles', an obviously garbled unit and figure; by far the heaviest knife in the lineup per the narrator, exact grams not recoverable, kept verbatim rather than guessed

  • 15Kizer
    61.85g

    very light

  • 16ICON
    109.15g
  • 17SOG
    127.66g
  • 18Zero Tolerance
    141g

    (right out at)

  • 19Boker

    captioned as '91.67%'; the trailing '%' does not fit the video's weight format and is kept verbatim as an unresolved artifact rather than guessed

Initial Sharpness BESS Lower Is Sharper

  • 1AOSILEY
    190

    called a great result for a $6 knife

  • 2Albatross
    205

    pretty sharp but not as sharp as AOSILEY

  • 3GW
    215
  • 4Mossy Oak
    165
  • 5Steinbrucke
    170
  • 6Crescent
    235

    described later as pretty dull to start

  • 7Old Timer
    195

    described as maybe not the sharpest but still pretty sharp

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    185
  • 9CRKT
    205

    stated as 40 points behind Mossy Oak's 165, which checks out (165+40=205)

  • 10Buck
    1753rd

    good enough to move into third place behind Steinbrucke at that point

  • 11Civivi
    130

    called very impressive

  • 12Kershaw
    160

    one of the sharpest knives in the lineup

  • 13CJRB
    185

    performed well

  • 14Gerber

    not given an explicit number at introduction; the later durability recap states only that Gerber 'started off the dest in the lineup' (dullest of all 19 brands), with no numeric starting score ever stated, only the post-test figure of 260

  • 15Kizer
    225
  • 16ICON
    175

    performed well

  • 17SOG
    1552nd

    very sharp, moved into second place behind Civivi at that point (subject dropped from the transcript sentence, resolved by testing-order position and later cross references)

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    220

    started duller than average for a knife at this price

  • 19Boker
    140

    extremely sharp; this figure only appears later in the durability-test recap, not in Boker's own introduction paragraph, which jumps straight from weight into the next section without a sharpness number

Lock Release Force (lb)

  • 1AOSILEY

    not stated; the lock-force test section opens mid comparison ('it takes a lot less force to unlock the albatross') implying AOSILEY's own figure was given just before this excerpt or as an implicit baseline, but no explicit AOSILEY number appears anywhere in the transcript, an apparent gap

  • 2Albatross
    1.37lb

    finished third-lowest (easiest to unlock) of all 19 brands per the closing recap

  • 3GW

    very close to 2

  • 4Mossy Oak
    4lb

    described as taking a little thumb and finger strength

  • 5Steinbrucke
    0.85lb

    the lowest (easiest to unlock) of all 19 brands per the closing recap

  • 6Crescent
    2.08lb

    about the same as GW

  • 7Old Timer
    7.345lb

    the most force required of any brand up to that point in the video

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    6.615lb

    also described as taking quite a bit of force

  • 9CRKT
    just over3lb

    a little more than average

  • 10Buck
    3.42lb

    a little more than average

  • 11Civivi
    1.79lb

    pretty easy to unlock

  • 12Kershaw
    1.62lb

    also pretty easy to unlock

  • 13CJRB
    2.67lb
  • 14Gerber
    3.97lb

    quite a bit of force from the thumb

  • 15Kizer
    1.25lb

    second-lowest (second-easiest to unlock) of all 19 brands per the closing recap, which also includes a stray fragment ('1.25 five') not otherwise explained

  • 16ICON
    1.745lb

    also pretty easy to unlock

  • 17SOG
    right at2lb
  • 18Zero Tolerance
    2.65lb

    pretty close to average

  • 19Boker

    captioned as 'only 2105 lb', almost certainly a dropped decimal point given every other brand in this test reads between 0.85 and 7.345 lb; kept verbatim as an unresolved artifact rather than corrected to a guessed value

Opening Smoothness (g)

  • 1AOSILEY
    105g

    described as quite a bit of force

  • 2Albatross
    97g
  • 3GW
    81g
  • 4Mossy Oak
    44g

    by far the smoothest yet at that point in the video

  • 5Steinbrucke
    28g

    even better (smoother) than Mossy Oak

  • 6Crescent
    33g
  • 7Old Timer
    91g

    described as a little stiffness and arthritis to be expected

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    82g

    about the same as GW

  • 9CRKT
    98g

    about the same as Albatross

  • 10Buck
    89g

    almost as stiff as Old Timer

  • 11Civivi
    11g

    (a mid-video comparison line separately states 'zero tolerance is the same as a civi at 13 G', which conflicts with the 11g figure stated directly for Civivi and confirmed again in the closing recap as 11g for both Civivi and Zero Tolerance; the mid-video 13g statement is kept as a flagged inconsistency rather than used)

  • 12Kershaw
    48g

    better than average

  • 13CJRB
    18g

    very easy and smooth

  • 14Gerber
    187g

    by far the stiffest (worst) opening force of all 19 brands

  • 15Kizer
    13g

    very smooth and easy to open, the same as SOG

  • 16ICON
    7g

    moved into the lead, the smoothest (lowest force) opening of all 19 brands

  • 17SOG
    13g

    the same as Kizer

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    11g

    (a mid-video line states 'zero tolerance is the same as a civi at 13 G', which conflicts with the closing recap's '11 G' figure for both Civivi and Zero Tolerance; the mid-video 13g statement is kept as a flagged inconsistency rather than used)

  • 19Boker
    15g

    very smooth

Sharpness After Osage Wood Test (BESS)

  • 1AOSILEY
    300BESS

    (up from 190)

  • 2Albatross
    310BESS

    (up from 205)

  • 3GW
    315BESS

    the dullest result yet at that point in the video

  • 4Mossy Oak
    350BESS

    the dullest result in the entire video

  • 5Steinbrucke
    240BESS

    held the sharpest edge yet at that point in the video

  • 6Crescent
    335BESS

    (up from 235)

  • 7Old Timer
    295BESS

    lost 100 sharpness points from 195

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    290BESS

    (up from 185), a lot of dulling

  • 9CRKT
    320BESS

    (up from 205)

  • 10Buck
    240BESS

    (up from 175), tied with Steinbrucke for the sharpest result at that point

  • 11Civivi
    265BESS

    (up from 130)

  • 12Kershaw
    235BESS1st

    (up from 160), moved into first place (best edge retention) at that point in the video

  • 13CJRB
    295BESS

    lost 110 points from 185

  • 14Gerber
    260BESS
  • 15Kizer

    captioned as 'held up well at 27', a dropped trailing digit; not recoverable precisely, kept as an unresolved artifact rather than guessed

  • 16ICON
    290BESS

    lost 115 points from 175

  • 17SOG
    225BESS1st

    held up well, moved into first place (over Kershaw) at that point in the video

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    220BESS

    essentially unchanged from its initial 220 score; the narrator explains that starting duller than average left it with less room to dull further during this test, a real result rather than a caption error

  • 19Boker
    210BESS

    (up from 140), still the sharpest blade in the lineup at that point in the video

Sharpness After Resharpen (BESS)

  • 1AOSILEY
    110BESS
  • 2Albatross
    105BESS

    sharper than AOSILEY's 110

  • 3GW
    125BESS

    described as the sharpest it could be made despite several attempts

  • 4Mossy Oak

    captioned as 'maxed out at5 sharpness points', a dropped leading digit; not recoverable precisely, kept as an unresolved artifact rather than guessed

  • 5Steinbrucke
    100BESS

    described as very easy to sharpen

  • 6Crescent
    115BESS
  • 7Old Timer
    105BESS
  • 8Smith & Wesson
    115BESS

    same sharpness as Crescent

  • 9CRKT
    120BESS

    not quite as sharp as Old Timer's 105

  • 10Buck
    100BESS

    just as sharp as Steinbrucke

  • 11Civivi
    105BESS
  • 12Kershaw
    110BESS
  • 13CJRB
    125BESS

    pretty challenging to sharpen

  • 14Gerber
    100BESS

    formed a very sharp knife edge

  • 15Kizer
    105BESS

    about the same sharpness as Gerber

  • 16ICON
    115BESS

    the same as SOG

  • 17SOG
    115BESS

    the same as ICON

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    105BESS
  • 19Boker
    105BESS

Sharpness After Bamboo Test (BESS)

  • 1AOSILEY
    145BESS

    held up really well for a $6 knife

  • 2Albatross
    185BESS

    (up from 105)

  • 3GW
    210BESS

    struggled to hold a blade edge

  • 4Mossy Oak
    215BESS

    dulled pretty badly

  • 5Steinbrucke
    195BESS
  • 6Crescent
    135BESS

    (only lost 20 points from 115), the smallest sharpness loss of any brand in this final test

  • 7Old Timer
    215BESS

    (lost 110 points from 105)

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    205BESS

    (up from 115), dulled quite a bit

  • 9CRKT
    195BESS

    (up from 120), dulled quite a bit

  • 10Buck
    180BESS

    described as unable to hold a sharp edge (as in the earlier durability test)

  • 11Civivi
    150BESS

    still very sharp

  • 12Kershaw
    135BESS

    did a great job of holding a blade edge, as it had in the earlier durability test

  • 13CJRB
    265BESS

    really struggled to hold a sharp edge, in really bad shape

  • 14Gerber
    150BESS

    did a fantastic job of holding a blade edge in both durability tests

  • 15Kizer
    155BESS

    also held a sharp blade edge in the first durability test and is still sharper than new

  • 16ICON
    125BESS2nd

    the sharpest knife in the lineup at that point; closing recap confirms second place overall behind Zero Tolerance

  • 17SOG
    130BESS

    a strong performer in both durability tests, much better than average; closing recap confirms a tie with Boker for the final spot behind Zero Tolerance and ICON

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    115BESS

    by far the best (sharpest) final result of all 19 brands

  • 19Boker
    130BESS

    tied with SOG for the final spot behind Zero Tolerance and ICON

Blade Tip Drop Test

  • 1AOSILEY

    held up really well with only a small amount of damage

  • 2Albatross

    direct hit, a little more damage than AOSILEY

  • 3GW

    blade dulled quickly on impact, a good indication the metal is soft; a lot of damage

  • 4Mossy Oak

    more damage than AOSILEY and Albatross but less than GW

  • 5Steinbrucke

    about the same amount of damage as Mossy Oak

  • 6Crescent

    one of the heaviest knives in the lineup; a little more blade tip damage than Steinbrucke

  • 7Old Timer

    seems pretty soft, quite a bit of damage

  • 8Smith & Wesson

    the direct hit caused a pretty bad bend to the blade tip, one of the worse outcomes in this test

  • 9CRKT

    pretty soft, quite a bit of damage

  • 10Buck

    a pretty heavy knife; blade tip took quite a bit of damage

  • 11Civivi

    held up really well, only a small amount of damage

  • 12Kershaw

    held a very sharp blade edge and the tip seems very durable; narrator calls out better quality blade steel than many of the other knives

  • 13CJRB

    some damage to the blade edge as well as a small bend to the blade tip

  • 14Gerber

    the heaviest knife tested; the blade tip survived the impact and still looks as good as new

  • 15Kizer

    a very lightweight knife; held up very well from the direct impact, just like Gerber

  • 16ICON

    wasn't happy about getting dropped, held up really well with just a small amount of damage

  • 17SOG

    held up really well, still looks as good as new

  • 18Zero Tolerance

    made of a very hard metal designed for a long-lasting durable edge; only a very small amount of damage

  • 19Boker

    constructed with very hard blade steel; the tip still looks as good as new

All measurements (6 more)+

Pivot Slop (mm)

  • 1AOSILEY
    10.45mm

    very sloppy and loose, as expected from a $6 knife

  • 2Albatross
    10.9mm

    even more sloppy and loose than AOSILEY

  • 3GW
    8.1mm

    moved into the lead (best so far) at that point in the video

  • 4Mossy Oak
    6.63mm

    by far the best stability yet at that point in the video

  • 5Steinbrucke
    just over10mm

    a lot of side to side movement

  • 6Crescent
    6.19mm

    even better than Mossy Oak, moved into the lead at that point

  • 7Old Timer
    8.58mm

    a little too much slop

  • 8Smith & Wesson
    7.77mm

    better than average

  • 9CRKT
    6.7mm3rd

    moved into third place behind Mossy Oak at that point

  • 10Buck
    7.41mm

    performed better than average

  • 11Civivi
    4.36mm3rd

    doing a terrific job, moved into the lead at that point; closing recap confirms third place overall behind Zero Tolerance and Boker

  • 12Kershaw
    10.7mm

    performed very well in most categories but this is a clear area for improvement

  • 13CJRB
    5.8mm

    offers a lot of blade stability

  • 14Gerber
    6.52mm

    quite a bit better than average

  • 15Kizer
    6.52mm

    performed the same as Gerber

  • 16ICON
    5.34mm2nd

    moved into second place behind Civivi

  • 17SOG
    7.37mm

    a little better than average; the brand name is dropped from this specific sentence in the transcript ('the is at 7.37 MM'), resolved by testing-order position between Kizer and ICON

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    2.86mm

    the best (most stable) of all 19 brands by a wide margin

  • 19Boker
    4.2mm2nd

    very good side to side stability, second place behind Zero Tolerance

Country Of Origin

  • 1AOSILEY

    China

  • 2Albatross

    China

  • 3GW

    China

  • 4Mossy Oak

    China

  • 5Steinbrucke

    not explicitly restated for this brand individually in the transcript (implied China like nearly every other brand, but not confirmed in words)

  • 7Old Timer

    China

  • 8Smith & Wesson

    China

  • 10Buck

    China

  • 11Civivi

    China

  • 12Kershaw

    China

  • 13CJRB

    China

  • 14Gerber

    China

  • 15Kizer

    China

  • 16ICON

    China

  • 17SOG

    China

  • 18Zero Tolerance

    United States

  • 19Boker

    Germany

  • 6Crescent
    not tested
  • 9CRKT
    not tested

Claims

  • 1AOSILEY

    high quality stainless steel blade, aluminum handle, liner lock

  • 2Albatross

    spring assisted, flipper deployment, 440 stainless steel blade, liner lock

  • 3GW

    compact, versatile, 440c stainless steel, liner lock, serrated blade, aluminum ergonomic handle

  • 6Crescent
    3.5in

    harpoon blade, premium stainless steel, easy-action flipper tab, liner lock; transcript states both 'product of Vietnam and finished in China' and, separately, 'a crescent is made in China', kept as two distinct statements rather than reconciled

  • 7Old Timer

    high carbon stainless steel, 2.9in drop point blade, wood handle, claimed 3.2 oz, back lock (most other brands in this video use a liner lock)

  • 8Smith & Wesson

    high carbon stainless steel blade, 2.8in blade length, claimed 3.5 oz, two thumb knobs, frame lock

  • 10Buck

    stainless steel blade for strength and edge retention; unlike most other brands in this video, has a frame lock rather than a liner lock; removable pocket clip

  • 11Civivi

    black stonewash D2 steel, ceramic ball bearing pivot construction, G10 handle, liner lock, described by the narrator as a number one seller on Amazon

  • 12Kershaw

    carbon infused black oxide coated blade, bright orange handle for visibility, liner lock, includes a window breaker

  • 13CJRB

    AR-RPM9 blade steel, stainless steel handle, button lock (a distinct lock type from most other brands' liner locks), claimed 3.7 oz, dual thumb studs

  • 14Gerber
    5c

    stainless steel blade (steel designation as captioned, kept verbatim)

  • 15Kizer

    German-made Nitro-V steel (as captioned; the steel type is Nitro-V, while the country of origin stated immediately after for the knife itself is China, kept as two separate, non-contradictory statements: a German steel used in a China-made knife), flipper plus liner lock combination

  • 16ICON

    ceramic ball bearings, premium D2 blade steel claim, low friction pivot point, blade length just over 3in, liner lock

  • 17SOG

    cryo 44c stainless steel (steel designation as captioned, kept verbatim), spring-assisted technology, liner lock

  • 18Zero Tolerance
    20

    CV stainless steel blade, titanium handle with glow-in-the-dark carbon fiber overlay, flipper with the KVT opening system

  • 19Boker

    hardness of 62 to 63 HRC, ball bearing blade for smooth and quick opening

  • 4Mossy Oak
    not tested
  • 5Steinbrucke
    not tested
  • 9CRKT
    not tested

Brand Resolution

  • 1AOSILEY

    captioned as osley, ocle, OS, and ocel across the video; resolved to AOSILEY via the description, the only brand at the $6 price point

  • 4Mossy Oak

    captioned as masio and Moke across the video; resolved to Mossy Oak via the description and the explicit later phrase 'not as sharp as a mossi oak'

  • 5Steinbrucke

    captioned as Stein Brook / Steinbrook throughout; resolved to Steinbrucke via the description

  • 15Kizer

    captioned as Kaiser throughout; resolved to Kizer via the description and testing-order position

  • 17SOG

    captioned as so, S so, and theog across the video; resolved to SOG via the description

  • 2Albatross
    not tested
  • 3GW
    not tested
  • 6Crescent
    not tested
  • 7Old Timer
    not tested
  • 8Smith & Wesson
    not tested
  • 9CRKT
    not tested
  • 10Buck
    not tested
  • 11Civivi
    not tested
  • 12Kershaw
    not tested
  • 13CJRB
    not tested
  • 14Gerber
    not tested
  • 16ICON
    not tested
  • 18Zero Tolerance
    not tested
  • 19Boker
    not tested

Features

  • 4Mossy Oak

    G10 handle, opens via thumb stud

  • 1AOSILEY
    not tested
  • 2Albatross
    not tested
  • 3GW
    not tested
  • 5Steinbrucke
    not tested
  • 6Crescent
    not tested
  • 7Old Timer
    not tested
  • 8Smith & Wesson
    not tested
  • 9CRKT
    not tested
  • 10Buck
    not tested
  • 11Civivi
    not tested
  • 12Kershaw
    not tested
  • 13CJRB
    not tested
  • 14Gerber
    not tested
  • 15Kizer
    not tested
  • 16ICON
    not tested
  • 17SOG
    not tested
  • 18Zero Tolerance
    not tested
  • 19Boker
    not tested

Retail Note

  • 16ICON

    sold at Harbor Freight

  • 1AOSILEY
    not tested
  • 2Albatross
    not tested
  • 3GW
    not tested
  • 4Mossy Oak
    not tested
  • 5Steinbrucke
    not tested
  • 6Crescent
    not tested
  • 7Old Timer
    not tested
  • 8Smith & Wesson
    not tested
  • 9CRKT
    not tested
  • 10Buck
    not tested
  • 11Civivi
    not tested
  • 12Kershaw
    not tested
  • 13CJRB
    not tested
  • 14Gerber
    not tested
  • 15Kizer
    not tested
  • 17SOG
    not tested
  • 18Zero Tolerance
    not tested
  • 19Boker
    not tested

How it was tested

  • factory out-of-box sharpness, BESS score (lower is sharper; per the video's own reference chart, roughly 50 to 75 for a double edged razor, 150 to 200 for a utility razor, 250 to 350 for a new high-end cutlery edge, 400+ needs maintenance, around 2000 for a dull butter knife)
  • blade lock release force in pounds
  • blade opening smoothness in grams of force
  • sharpness (BESS) after 15 back-and-forth passes across osage orange wood with 5 lb of downward force
  • sharpness (BESS) after resharpening all blades to a deliberately aggressive 17 degree edge
  • sharpness (BESS) after 50 back-and-forth passes across a bamboo cutting board following the resharpen
  • blade lock strength: 25 lb of downward force applied to the open blade (all 19 brands held up fine, no per-brand differentiation reported)
  • blade tip durability: dropped from about 4.5ft onto mild steel, qualitative damage assessment
  • blade pivot slop/wobble in mm of side to side movement, measured with a dial indicator 3.5in from the pivot

the booker came out on top with the best average finisher rating of 3.9

From the test video verdict.
Data notes and caveats

This transcript systematically inserts a stray dollar sign before plain BESS sharpness-score numbers (e.g. 'a sharpness score of $190', 'sharpness of $220'), which are scores on the video's own 0 to 2000+ BESS scale, not prices; every such figure in products[] has been treated as a BESS score, not a price, and the dollar sign discarded as a caption artifact rather than carried forward as a dollar value. Four of the 19 brands (Mossy Oak, Steinbrucke, CRKT, Kizer) have no price stated anywhere in the transcript, an unusually large and clustered gap versus other Project Farm showdowns. Several weight readings carry unexplained '%' or unit artifacts (GW, Mossy Oak, Smith & Wesson, Boker) or are outright missing (Crescent, Steinbrucke, CRKT) or garbled beyond recovery (Gerber's 'miles' unit); all are preserved verbatim per product with the pattern flagged here. The overall winner is explicit and score-based: the narrator converts raw per-test results into a 1st-through-19th average finisher rating, with Boker on top at 3.9 and Civivi a close second at 4.2, which the narrator also names as a personal everyday-carry pick over the numeric winner. Zero Tolerance gets an explicit, unusual near-miss callout: 'it would have definitely won The Showdown if it had a very sharp knife edge when new,' since it won or tied for best in the final sharpness-retention and pivot-stability tests but was dragged down by a mediocre out-of-box sharpness score. ICON gets an audience-specific value recommendation ('if you're a Harbor Freight customer the icon knife is of very good quality') distinct from the numeric winner and runner-up. Two brand pairs have internally contradictory opening-smoothness figures (Civivi/Zero Tolerance: an 11g figure for each stated directly and confirmed in the closing recap, versus one mid-video line claiming both are 13g); the 11g figures are used as the better-supported value with the conflicting line flagged rather than silently dropped.

More Hand Tools